Hero background

Comparing Stories

English • Year 3 • 60 • 27 students • Created with AI following Aligned with Australian Curriculum (F-10)

English
3Year 3
60
27 students
8 July 2025

Teaching Instructions

outcome EN2-RECOM-01 Reads and comprehends texts for wide purposes using knowledge of text structures and language, and by monitoring comprehension. Content Identify similarities and compare differences within and between texts by making text-to-self, text-to-text and text-to-world connections.

Books Little J and Big Cuz The Stormy Night by Adam Thompson and The Little Refugee by Anh Do

I want differentiation for this lesson, emergent, sound and advanced.

Lesson Overview

This 60-minute lesson is designed for Year 3 students in Australia, focusing on reading comprehension aligned with the Australian Curriculum (v9) English content descriptor EN2-RECOM-01. Students will read Little J and Big Cuz: The Stormy Night by Adam Thompson and The Little Refugee by Anh Do. The lesson develops students' ability to identify similarities and differences within and between texts, making text-to-self, text-to-text, and text-to-world connections.

Learning Objectives

  • Read and comprehend texts for wide purposes using knowledge of text structures and language by monitoring comprehension (AC v9, EN2-RECOM-01).
  • Identify similarities and compare differences within and between texts by making text-to-self, text-to-text, and text-to-world connections.
  • Develop critical thinking about characters, events, and themes in texts relevant to their own experiences and wider world knowledge.

Australian Curriculum Links

  • EN2-RECOM-01: Reads and comprehends texts for wide purposes using knowledge of text structures and language, and by monitoring comprehension.
  • Referenced from AC v9 English Year 3 content description and elaborations.
  • Emphasis on comparing and contrasting ideas across texts from AC v9 elaborations.

Class Size: 27

Duration: 60 minutes


Lesson Plan Details

Materials Needed

  • Little J and Big Cuz: The Stormy Night by Adam Thompson (print or digital copies)
  • The Little Refugee by Anh Do (print or digital copies)
  • Whiteboard and markers or digital interactive board
  • Venn diagram worksheets
  • Writing materials for students
  • Chart paper for group work

Lesson Breakdown

1. Introduction – 10 minutes

Objective: Build background knowledge and prepare students for reading.

  • Engage students: Ask students if they have experienced any big storms or know anyone who has had to move to a new place (text-to-self and text-to-world connections).
  • Show the covers of the two books and introduce the authors and titles.
  • Briefly discuss the themes: The Stormy Night focuses on community and weather events, while The Little Refugee deals with migration and resilience.
  • Set the concept: Today we’ll discover how these stories are alike and different, and how they connect to our lives and the world.

2. Reading and Comprehension – 20 minutes

Objective: Read both texts and monitor comprehension.

  • Differentiated Reading Approach:

    • Emergent readers (approx. 9 students): Read aloud with the teacher or a teaching assistant, focusing on listening and following along.
    • Sound readers (approx. 12 students): Read excerpts independently or in pairs with support, pausing to discuss key vocabulary and ideas.
    • Advanced readers (approx. 6 students): Read independently, encouraged to note interesting phrases or questions about characters or events.
  • Use think-aloud strategies to model comprehension and monitoring.

  • Ask comprehension questions after each reading to check understanding. Example questions:

    • What happened in the story?
    • Who are the main characters?
    • What problems did the characters face?

3. Comparing Texts – 15 minutes

Objective: Identify similarities and differences via text-to-self, text-to-text, and text-to-world connections.

  • Model how to use a Venn diagram to compare key elements such as:

    • Characters
    • Setting
    • Problem
    • Solutions
    • Emotions and resilience
    • Community impact
  • Students then complete the Venn diagram in pairs or small groups; differentiated task:

    • Emergent: Focus on simple ideas like characters and setting with picture cues.
    • Sound: Include problem and solution comparison with sentence starters.
    • Advanced: Add emotional responses and world connections (e.g., why people migrate, dealing with storms globally).
  • Groups share key points with the class, enhancing oral language skills.


4. Reflective Writing – 10 minutes

Objective: Solidify understanding and make personal connections.

  • Prompt students to write a short paragraph or sentence completing one of the following:
    • "Both books made me think about..."
    • "I felt like the character in ... when..."
    • "The stories help me understand something about our community or the world because..."
  • Differentiation:
    • Emergent: Complete sentence starters or draw a picture related to the prompt.
    • Sound: Write simple paragraphs with support.
    • Advanced: Write detailed personal reflections including text examples.

5. Conclusion and Assessment – 5 minutes

Objective: Assess comprehension and connections made.

  • Brief whole-class discussion: What did we learn from comparing these two stories?
  • Collect Venn diagrams and writing samples to assess students’ ability to compare texts and connect to self and world.

Formative Assessment:

  • Observation of group discussions and participation.
  • Review of written reflections and Venn diagrams, identifying comprehension and depth of connection.

Differentiation Summary

LevelReading SupportComparing ActivityWriting Task
EmergentTeacher/read-aloud, picture supportSimple categories (characters, setting) with visualsSentence starters or drawing
SoundPaired reading, vocabulary supportProblem/solution added, sentence promptsSimple paragraphs
AdvancedIndependent readingEmotional and world connectionsDetailed reflections with text reference

Teacher Notes and Tips

  • Pre-teach vocabulary such as refugee, storm, community, and resilience.
  • Use questioning techniques to scaffold for emergent and sound readers.
  • Encourage empathy and respect during text-to-self and text-to-world discussions.
  • Use multimedia resources if available, e.g., listening to author interviews about the books or watching related videos.
  • Incorporate Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives sensitively if discussing community resilience.

This lesson plan responds directly to the curriculum emphasis on reading comprehension and textual connection skills (EN2-RECOM-01) and provides engaging, age-appropriate activities that develop deep understanding of narrative texts within students’ cultural and social frameworks.

Create Your Own AI Lesson Plan

Join thousands of teachers using Kuraplan AI to create personalized lesson plans that align with Aligned with Australian Curriculum (F-10) in minutes, not hours.

AI-powered lesson creation
Curriculum-aligned content
Ready in minutes

Created with Kuraplan AI

Generated using gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14

🌟 Trusted by 1000+ Schools

Join educators across Australia