Exploring Biblical Conflicts

Curriculum Area: Religious Education – Biblical Studies and Theology

Australian Curriculum Level: Year 11 (Stage 6 Syllabus)
Focus: Hermeneutics, theology, and cultural conflicts in Christianity

---

Lesson Overview (120 minutes)

This lesson is part of a module that examines core topics in Bible interpretation (hermeneutics), addresses theological and cultural challenges in church contexts, and unpacks issues emerging in modern-day Christian practice. Students will engage with theoretical concepts, apply interpretive methodologies, and work collaboratively to explore culturally relevant examples tailored to Indigenous and Australian societal contexts.

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will:

1. Identify and assess areas in Christian belief and practice causing controversy, especially for Indigenous Christians.
2. Understand the principles of Biblical hermeneutics and apply foundational interpretative methods.
3. Evaluate contemporary "grey" areas in church life and distinguish fundamentalist versus pluralistic approaches.
4. Analyse conflicts between Christian theology and secular/Indigenous culture with sensitivity.

---

Materials Needed

• Student booklets with blank templates for group research findings
• Bible (physical or app-based versions)
• Handouts with case studies on Indigenous Christian issues and “grey” area scenarios
• Whiteboard/markers or digital collaborative tools (e.g., Jamboard)
• A timer for structured group activities

---

Lesson Structure

1. Introduction (15 minutes)

Objective: Engage students and outline the importance of Biblical interpretation and theology in addressing conflicts.

1. Welcome and Brief Overview
   Greet the students and provide a short introduction to the topic. Discuss why understanding hermeneutics and theology is essential in a multicultural context like Australia. Briefly introduce the significance of addressing Indigenous perspectives in Christianity.

2. Starter Activity: Analysis of Perspectives (5 minutes)

   • Prompt: Write “The Bible” in bold on the whiteboard.
   • Ask students, “What shapes the way people interpret the Bible? Is it the same for everyone?”
   • Write their answers as a mind map (e.g., upbringing, culture, church traditions, personal experiences).

3. Discussion (10 minutes)
   Transition into the idea of interpreting scripture using principles of Biblical hermeneutics. Ask students:

   • “What happens when cultural traditions and scriptural teachings clash?”
   • “How might interpretations differ between Indigenous Christians and Western Christians?”

---

2. Activity 1: Unpacking Conflicts (25 minutes)

Objective: Identify real-life conflicts between Indigenous culture and Christianity.

1. Divide students into pairs (if uneven, one group will have three students). Provide each pair with a case study involving an Indigenous cultural conflict or tension with Christianity. Examples:

   • Case #1: Traditional ceremonies versus Sabbath observance in Indigenous Seventh-day Adventist communities.
   • Case #2: The question of ancestral respect or spiritual traditions and biblical commandments.
   • Case #3: Different models of leadership in Indigenous communities versus hierarchical church organisation.

2. Discussion Questions (on worksheets):

   • What is the cultural issue in the case study?
   • What biblical principles are in tension?
   • How might a fair resolution be achieved?

3. Presentations: (15 minutes)
   Groups present their findings informally. Diversity of responses is encouraged, as answers should include cultural sensitivity while grounded in theological evaluation.

---

3. Hermeneutics and Interpretation (25 minutes)

Objective: Develop a basic framework for Biblical hermeneutics and practise using it.

1. Mini-lesson (10 minutes):

   • Define Biblical hermeneutics: The art and science of interpreting scripture.
   • Provide students with five core principles of interpretation:
     • Context is key (historical, cultural, literary).
     • Interpret scripture with scripture (unity of the Bible).
     • Analyse genre (narrative, poetry, prophecy, epistle).
     • Mind the original audience’s perspective.
     • Apply timeless lessons, not just past-specific instructions.

2. Application Exercise (15 minutes):
   Ask students to apply these principles to a passage about controversial issues. Example:

   • 1 Corinthians 8:1-13 (Food sacrificed to idols – a biblical “grey” area).
     Guiding Question: “How do we extract meaning for today while respecting the text’s context?”

---

4. "Grey" Areas Debate (30 minutes)

Objective: Define “grey” areas, analyse their implications, and contrast competing approaches to resolving them.

1. Definitions and Comparisons (10 minutes):

   • Define “grey” areas (e.g., morally or doctrinally unclear topics not directly addressed by scripture).
   • Contrast two approaches to these challenges:
     • Fundamentalism: Strict, literal application of scripture, rejecting cultural nuance.
     • Pluralism: Open to diverse perspectives within the boundaries of core Christian beliefs.

   Provide examples:

   • Ethical dilemmas like tattoos, alcohol consumption, or differences in worship styles.
   • Ask the class to suggest additional “grey” areas.

2. Debate Preparation:
   Split students into two groups:

   • Group 1: Take the fundamentalist perspective for a scenario (e.g., wearing traditional Indigenous dress in church settings).
   • Group 2: Take the pluralistic perspective.

3. Debate: (15 minutes)
   Moderate a lively debate. Encourage mutual respect, asking students to evaluate both positions and identify potential compromises.

---

5. Reflection and Summary (25 minutes)

Objective: Consolidate learning and critical thinking skills.

1. Introduce Biblical Criticism & the Seventh-day Adventist Approach:
   Focus on how Adventist Christianity addresses critical biblical interpretation and engages with culturally diverse issues. For example:

   • The importance of sola scriptura (scripture alone as the foundation of belief).
   • The balance between cultural sensitivity and doctrinal integrity.

2. Student Reflection Activity (15 minutes):
   Ask students to journal responses to:

   • “What is one critical lesson you have learned about interpreting scripture today?”
   • “How does today’s discussion change your view of conflicts in church life or theology?”
   • “What strategies will you adopt when facing ‘grey’ areas in your own church setting?”

3. Wrap-Up Discussion (10 minutes):
   Facilitate an open sharing session about what students learned and any lingering questions.

---

Assessment Tasks

1. Formative Assessment (During Activities):
   Assess group participation, ability to articulate perspectives, and critical evaluation of case studies.

2. Summative Assessment (Post-Lesson Homework):
   Students will write a 300-word reflection paper responding to one of the lesson’s key questions, such as:

   • “How should Christians reconcile conflicts between Indigenous culture and the Bible?”
   • “What is the role of context in interpreting biblical ‘grey’ areas?”

---

Extension Tasks for Advanced Students

• Conduct a comparison of two theological traditions’ approaches to resolving cultural conflicts (e.g., Pentecostal vs Adventist).
• Research a case where an Australian Indigenous church successfully integrated cultural practices with biblical theology.

---

Evaluation

At the end of the module, students will evaluate their confidence with hermeneutics and cultural conflict resolution by completing a short anonymous survey to help refine teaching methods and identify gaps in understanding.

---

Teacher Notes

This lesson blends theoretical knowledge and practical application to equip students with tools to think critically and engage constructively in real-world theological challenges. Tailoring the case studies to culturally relevant Australian contexts ensures inclusivity and deeper engagement with the material.