Introduction to Argument

Year Level

10

Duration

55 minutes

Class Size

25 students

---

Unit Overview

This is Lesson 1 of 30 in the unit "Mastering Argument Analysis." Students will be introduced to the fundamental concepts of argument analysis, focusing on recognising arguments in media and everyday life, and developing key metalanguage related to arguments. This foundational lesson sets the stage for critical engagement with texts throughout the unit.

---

Australian Curriculum Alignment

Content Descriptions (English - Year 10)

• ACELY1751: Analyse and evaluate the effectiveness of a wide range of persuasive texts, identifying and analysing the ways authors use evidence, reasoning, and stylistic devices to influence audiences.
• ACELY1750: Plan, draft and publish imaginative, informative, and persuasive texts, selecting aspects of subject matter and particular language, visual, and audio features for different purposes and audiences.
• ACELY1753: Develop a critical understanding of how language use in media and everyday texts positions audiences and constructs viewpoints.

General Capabilities

• Literacy: Comprehension, critical analysis, and argument construction.
• Critical and Creative Thinking: Analysing arguments, distinguishing fact from opinion and bias.
• Personal and Social Capability: Recognising influence and constructing respectful arguments.

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

1. Define what an argument is and describe its purpose in everyday and media contexts.
2. Identify and explain key metalanguage terms related to argument analysis such as claim, evidence, reasoning, counterargument, and bias.
3. Recognise simple arguments in short texts or media excerpts.
4. Understand why critical analysis of arguments is important in daily life and media literacy.

---

Lesson Outline and Timing

Time	Activity	Description	Resources
0–5 minutes	Engage: Introduction & Context Setting	Warm-up discussion on where students encounter arguments in daily life and media.	Whiteboard, markers
5–15 minutes	Explain: Key Concepts & Metalanguage	Teacher-led presentation introducing the concept of argument and key terms (claim, evidence...).	Slide presentation, handout with key terms
15–25 minutes	Explore: Analysing Simple Arguments	Students work in pairs to identify arguments and supporting elements in selected media snippets (e.g. news headlines, short ads).	Printed media excerpts, highlighters
25–35 minutes	Discuss: Why Argument Analysis Matters	Whole class discussion on the importance of analysing arguments critically in everyday and media contexts.	Whiteboard or chart paper
35–45 minutes	Explain & Model: Argument Components	Teacher models analysis of a short media text argument, identifying claim, evidence, reasoning, and bias.	Projector or interactive whiteboard
45–53 minutes	Apply: Quick Write Reflection	Students write a brief response explaining why understanding arguments is important and list three argument terms learnt.	Paper or device for writing
53–55 minutes	Consolidate & Preview Next Lesson	Recap key points and explain how this connects to deeper argument analysis in the unit.	Verbal summary

---

Detailed Teaching Notes

0–5 min: Engage

• Initiate a brief discussion: "Where do you see arguments around you? Can anyone give examples from social media, TV, or conversations?"
• Write student responses on the board to create a mind map of "Arguments around us."

5–15 min: Explain

• Define an argument: "An argument is a reasoned way of presenting a point of view about something."
• Introduce metalanguage:
  • Claim: The main point or position.
  • Evidence: Facts, data, or examples supporting the claim.
  • Reasoning: Explanation of how the evidence supports the claim.
  • Counterargument: An opposing view.
  • Bias: A tendency or preference that might affect impartiality.
• Provide handouts with definitions and examples for later reference.

15–25 min: Explore

• Provide pairs with short media excerpts (e.g., headlines, commercials, social media posts).
• Task: Identify if there is an argument, what the claim is, and what supports it. Highlight or annotate accordingly.
• Circulate and assist.

25–35 min: Discuss

• Gather insights from the pairs.
• Facilitate discussion on why analysing these elements matters, touching on misinformation and influence in media.

35–45 min: Explain & Model

• Project a media text (e.g., a short opinion column or advertisement).
• Model annotating the text to find claim, evidence, reasoning, and bias.
• Think aloud to guide analysis.

45–53 min: Apply

• Students write a short reflection answering:
  • Why is it important to understand arguments?
  • List and briefly explain three terms they learned today.
• This formative task checks understanding and encourages personal connection.

53–55 min: Consolidate & Preview

• Recap key points.
• Explain that future lessons will build on these foundations, including evaluating arguments and creating their own.

---

Assessment for Learning

• Observation of pair discussions to check ability to identify arguments.
• Quick write reflections for individual understanding of concepts and terminology.
• Teacher feedback in next lesson to address any misconceptions.

---

Resources

• Printed media excerpts (adapted for Year 10 reading level)
• Handout of argument terminology and definitions
• Slide presentation for explanations
• Projector or interactive whiteboard
• Writing materials or digital devices for reflections

---

Differentiation Strategies

• For students needing support: Provide a simplified glossary and scaffolded worksheet for the pair activity.
• For advanced learners: Challenge to identify potential counterarguments or bias in media excerpts.
• Use multimodal texts (videos, images) to cater to different learning styles.

---

Cross-Curricular Links

• Media Literacy: Critical engagement with media texts.
• Civics and Citizenship: Understanding arguments contributes to informed decision-making.

---

Teacher Reflection Prompt

After the lesson, reflect on:

• How effectively did students grasp key metalanguage terms?
• Were examples relatable and clear?
• How engaged were students in the pair and class discussions?
• What adjustments might improve comprehension or participation?

---

This lesson plan is designed to inspire Year 10 students in Australia to begin mastering argument analysis through active learning and connection to real-world texts, closely aligned with the Australian Curriculum (v9) English standards ACELY1750, ACELY1751, and ACELY1753 .