Reflection and Revisions

Year Level

Year 10

Duration

90 minutes

Class Size

12 students

---

WALT (We Are Learning To)

• Evaluate our personal artwork critically.
• Use feedback to revise and refine artwork.
• Reflect on our artistic intentions and processes.

---

Success Criteria

• Submit updated artwork demonstrating clear refinements.
• Participate constructively in peer critiques.
• Write a reflection articulating changes made and reasons for those changes.
• Show evidence of understanding how feedback can enhance artistic outcomes.

---

Australian Curriculum Links

Visual Arts — Years 9 & 10

• AC9AVA10C01: Evaluate critical feedback when planning, developing and refining their visual arts practice.
• AC9AVA10E01: Investigate how artists develop personal expression to represent, communicate, and challenge ideas.
• General Capabilities: Critical and Creative Thinking; Personal and Social Capability.

---

Lesson Overview

This session emphasises iterative artistic development through evaluation and revision. Students will engage in peer critiques aimed at constructive feedback, followed by applying this to refine their acrylic artworks inspired by Picasso. The teacher’s role will be facilitating reflective conversations and encouraging students to articulate their artistic intentions.

---

Resources Needed

• Students' current artworks (acrylic paintings inspired by Picasso)
• Art materials for revisions (acrylic paints, brushes, palettes, water containers, rags)
• Reflection worksheets with guiding questions (dyslexia-friendly, clear font, ample spacing)
• Peer critique guidelines (simple sentence starters and feedback frameworks)
• Document cameras or smartboards to display artworks (optional)
• Timer for managing activity segments

---

Lesson Plan

1. Introduction and Setting the Stage (10 minutes)

• Welcome and brief review of previous lessons focused on Picasso's acrylic techniques.
• Introduce today’s WALT and success criteria.
• Explain the importance of reflection and revision in the artistic process.
• Share how feedback is a tool for growth, not criticism.
• Display exemplars of artwork revisions.

2. Peer Critique in Small Groups (25 minutes)

• Divide class into groups of 3-4.
• Provide peer critique guidelines to scaffold effective, positive feedback.
• Rotate artworks within the groups; each student shares their intent and receives feedback focused on:
• Technical skill and use of acrylics
• Composition, colour, and form
• Emotional or conceptual impact
• Suggestions for refinement
• Teacher circulates to support conversations and provide feedback models.

Dyslexia-friendly option: Provide printed feedback templates with sentence starters such as “I like how you…”, “I wonder if you could…”, “What if you tried…”.

3. Individual Reflection and Revision (40 minutes)

• Students review feedback and reflect on their own artistic intentions using a provided worksheet with guiding questions:
• What have I learned from my peers’ feedback?
• What aspects of my work do I want to improve or change?
• How do my revisions align with my artistic goals?
• Students then use provided art materials to make revisions to their artwork.
• Teacher supports individual students as needed, differentiating by ability, encouraging those who might need more scaffolding to focus on smaller, manageable changes.

4. Sharing Revisions and Reflection Summaries (10 minutes)

• Students display their updated artworks.
• Volunteers briefly share what changes they made and why, referring to reflections.
• Encourage positive, specific language to reinforce learning.

5. Conclusion and Submission (5 minutes)

• Collect updated artworks and reflection worksheets.
• Recap the importance of reflection and revision in creative processes.
• Briefly preview Lesson 10, focusing on finishing and presenting works.

---

Differentiation Strategies

• For diverse learners:
• Provide visual and verbal explanations.
• Use peer support and group work to scaffold understanding.
• Break down feedback into positive, constructive, and actionable parts.
• For students with dyslexia:
• Use dyslexia-friendly fonts and layouts on printed materials.
• Provide oral instructions and allow verbal reflections as alternatives.
• For higher ability students:
• Encourage deeper analysis during peer critique (e.g., examining symbolism, technique adaptation).
• Suggest exploring innovative revisions or mixed media extensions.

---

Reflective Prompts for Students

• How does your revised artwork better represent your artistic vision?
• In what ways did the feedback influence your creative decisions?
• What challenges did you face during revision, and how did you resolve them?
• How do you feel about your artwork now compared to before the revision?

---

By structuring the lesson with conversation-based peer critiques, reflective practice, and hands-on revision aligned with the Australian Curriculum standards for Year 10 Visual Arts, this lesson engages students in meaningful artistic growth, producing refined works inspired by Picasso’s acrylic techniques and fostering critical thinking and self-expression skills.

---

This plan is designed for a class of 12 students, ensuring adequate hands-on time and rich dialogue, capturing the teacher's preference for fun and conversational learning with diverse abilities in mind. The integration of reflection and revision aligns specifically with the Australian Curriculum's content codes for critical evaluation and refinement of artworks.