Unit 4: Global Impacts

Lesson 19: 9/11 and the Rise of Islamophobia

Subject: New Zealand History
Year Level: Year 11
Curriculum Alignment: Social Sciences – History | NCEA Level 1
Achievement Objective:
Students will examine how historical events have shaped global issues and identities, with a focus on significance and perspectives (NCEA History Learning Matrix: Big Idea – Understanding Significance and Understanding Perspectives).
Lesson Duration: 50 minutes
Class Size: 33 students

---

Learning Intentions

By the end of the lesson, students will:

• Understand the societal response to 9/11 in terms of anti-Muslim sentiment.
• Explore Islamophobia as a global and local historical consequence.
• Analyse diverse perspectives and experiences related to Muslim communities post-9/11.

Success Criteria

Students will:

• Identify key examples of Islamophobia following 9/11 globally and in Aotearoa New Zealand.
• Explain links between the 9/11 attacks and societal shifts in perceptions of Muslim communities.
• Reflect critically on how individual and collective identities are impacted by prejudice and media representation.

---

Required Materials

• Projector and whiteboard
• Printed handouts with quotes and media headlines
• Inquiry prompt cards (included below)
• Sticky notes
• Student exercise books
• A3 poster paper (7-8 sheets for group use)
• Markers or coloured pens

---

Lesson Breakdown

0–5 mins | Karakia and Engagement Question

Karakia (Whakawātea) – Invite a student to lead
Quick Prompt:

“When you hear the word ‘Islamophobia’, what comes to mind?”
Facilitate a short verbal brainstorm; record 5–6 responses on the board without judgement or elaboration to provide a pulse check.

---

5–15 mins | Critical Source Analysis: Media Headlines

Activity: Students will be given a handout with a range of global media headlines from the week following 9/11. These headlines should be carefully curated to show a difference between general news and those implying religious bias or stereotyping.

Instructions:
Working in pairs:

• Highlight language that may have contributed to anti-Muslim sentiment
• Circle loaded words or generalisations
• Discuss: How might this shape readers’ ideas about Islam?

Teacher Role: Circulate, prompt students with questions such as:

• “What image does this headline create?”
• “Does it refer to individuals or entire groups?”

Mini-plenary (3 mins) – Ask 2–3 pairs to share examples with the class.

---

15–25 mins | Personal Perspectives: Testimonies Through Time

Resource: Students receive quote cards (different for each table group) containing excerpts from interviews or opinion pieces by Muslim individuals in the US, UK, and NZ recounting their experiences in the decade following 9/11.

Task (In groups of 4–5):

• Read the provided testimony as a group
• Summarise the emotion and identify the main consequence described
• Write ONE powerful sentence on a sticky note that captures what society failed to understand in this story

Group Share (5 mins): Place sticky notes on the whiteboard under a shared heading: “What Was Misunderstood?” Allow students to read each other’s insights silently.

---

25–40 mins | Making Links: Localising Islamophobia

Discussion Prompt:

“Did Islamophobia happen in Aotearoa New Zealand too?”

Pose provocative local examples:

• The 2007 Operation Eight (Urewera raids – briefly mention stereotyping concerns)
• Media images of Muslim communities after 9/11
• Christchurch Mosque Attacks – as a later manifestation of warped public narratives

Activity: Community Connection Poster
Each group chooses ONE example and creates an A3 poster with two halves:

• "Then" – What caused this sentiment/perception?
• "Now" – How should we respond and educate?

Supports for Students: Sentence starters like:

• “A key misunderstanding was…”
• “To support better understanding, our community could…”

---

40–48 mins | Reflection, Writing, and Whai Whakaaro

Individual Task – Personal Response (5–8 mins):
Write a short reflection in your exercise book:

“In what ways can we challenge historical narratives that create fear or bias toward a group?”

Encourage inclusion of specific terms: prejudice, perspective, historical consequence, community identity.

---

48–50 mins | Closing and Whakataukī Connection

Teacher closes with this whakataukī relevant to understanding and bridging perspectives:

“He aha te mea nui o te ao? He tāngata! He tāngata! He tāngata!”
(What is the most important thing in the world? It is people! It is people! It is people!)

Remind students their historical thinking must be applied with humanity.

---

Assessment Opportunity

Formative:
Teacher to collect student reflection entries to check understanding of significance and perspectives. Look for evidence of empathy, contextual understanding, and depth of thought.

Group poster presentations may contribute to internal assessment preparation depending on course structure.

---

Extension/Next Steps

• Preparation for Lesson 20: “Policy, Power, and Airport Security” – Students will explore how international security policies shifted post-9/11 and their effect on citizens.
• Homework: Students reflect on a time they witnessed or experienced generalisation or bias, and consider what historical ideas may have influenced that moment (self-directed journaling – not to be submitted).

---

Note for Teachers

This lesson pushes students beyond surface-level understanding into empathetic historical inquiry while aligning with Aotearoa’s vision for critical, culturally aware citizens. Consider connecting with a local Muslim leader, historian or activist for an optional future Q&A session to deepen learning.