Sharing Opinions Effectively

Learning Objectives (WALT)

• WALT identify and articulate our own opinions about characters and themes in A Christmas Carol
• WALT support opinions with evidence from the text
• WALT listen and respond respectfully to others’ viewpoints
• WALT develop confidence in discussion using subject-specific vocabulary

(Linked National Curriculum: English - Reading; Spoken Language; GCSE PoS)

• Reading: understand, describe, analyse and evaluate texts, using appropriate terminology;
• Spoken Language: use spoken language confidently in different contexts for different purposes and audiences;
• Speaking and Listening: listen and respond appropriately to others, including in discussions and debates

---

Success Criteria

• I can clearly express my opinion about a character or theme.
• I can find and explain evidence from the text to support my opinion.
• I can ask questions and respond thoughtfully to my peers’ opinions.
• I use subject-specific vocabulary such as ‘redemption’, ‘generosity’, ‘social criticism’.

---

Resources

• Copies of A Christmas Carol (dyslexia-friendly editions available)
• Whiteboard and markers
• Sticky notes
• Discussion sentence starters (printed cards)
• Timer

---

Lesson Outline (20 minutes)

1. Introduction (3 minutes)

• Teacher explains WALT and sets the scene: Today we will explore how to share opinions about A Christmas Carol using evidence.
• Brief recap of key themes and characters (Scrooge, Marley, the spirits). Use dyslexia-friendly large-font visuals on the board.

2. Modelled Activity (5 minutes)

• Teacher demonstrates how to share an opinion: “I think Scrooge changes because he feels remorse for his past behaviour. This is shown when the Ghost of Christmas Past shows him his lonely childhood.”
• Teacher writes opinion and evidence on whiteboard in two columns.
• Highlight use of sentence starters: “I believe...”, “This is shown when...”, “It suggests that...”

3. Paired Discussion (8 minutes)

• Students split into pairs (2 pairs, 4 students) to share one opinion each about either a character or theme.
• Use sticky notes to write down their opinion and one piece of evidence from the text.
• Each pair uses sentence starter cards to scaffold their language.
• Teacher circulates, supports language, and prompts deeper thinking with questions like "Why do you think this?" or "How does this compare with another character?"

4. Group Sharing & Feedback (4 minutes)

• Each pair shares one opinion and evidence aloud.
• Other pair listens and asks one clarifying question or offers a contrasting opinion politely.
• Teacher provides positive feedback focused on clarity, use of evidence, and respectful listening.

---

Differentiation Strategies

• Provide dyslexia-friendly editions and/or text-to-speech technology for students with reading difficulties.
• Sentence starters and sticky notes support those needing language scaffolding.
• For students needing extra support, they can focus on one character or theme only with simplified evidence.
• More confident learners encouraged to compare two characters or themes.

---

Extension Activities for Advanced Learners

• Challenge them to analyse how Dickens uses language to create sympathy or criticism.
• Write a 3-sentence paragraph giving an opinion, supporting it with two pieces of evidence and a literary term.
• Encourage them to consider the Victorian social context that influenced Dickens’ themes.

---

Assessment and Reflection

• Formative assessment through observation of paired discussion and group feedback.
• Exit ticket: each student writes one opinion phrase and one piece of supporting evidence from the lesson.
• Reflection prompt: “How did sharing your opinion and listening to others help you understand the story better?”

---

This lesson plan effectively integrates speaking, listening, and reading skills while aligning with English National Curriculum aims for Year 11 students. It accommodates different learning needs and encourages critical thinking in a collaborative, respectful environment.