Mastering Essay Craft

Subject: Social Studies

Grade Level: 11th Grade
Curriculum: Cambridge International AICE Global Perspectives & Research (US adaptation)
Lesson Duration: 45 minutes
Student Goal: Learn to convert outlines into a polished, substantial Paper 2 essay (up to 2000 words) for AICE standards.

---

Learning Objectives:

By the end of this lesson, students will:

1. Understand the key components of Paper 2 in AICE Global Perspectives and its relevance to a persuasive academic essay.
2. Apply editing techniques that focus on structure, argument development, and source integration.
3. Produce a partial, highly polished draft from their outline in preparation for a completed essay.

---

Materials Needed

• Student outlines for Paper 2 (pre-prepared as homework)
• Sample high-scoring Paper 2 essays (provided by the teacher)
• Colored pens and sticky notes for editing activities
• Large projector or smartboard for visual aids
• Printed checklist for AICE evaluation criteria

---

Lesson Outline

Warm-Up (5 Minutes)

• Purpose: Re-establish familiarity with the essay goals and criteria.
• Activity:
  1. Begin with an engaging question: "What makes an essay argument persuasive enough to change someone's mind?" Give students 2 minutes to reflect and share responses.
  2. Project the essential AICE Paper 2 criteria (Quality of Argument, Evidence, Research, and Evaluation). Relate these criteria to the responses shared.
  3. Briefly review the key differences between an outline and a full essay (e.g., depth of explanation, flow, tone).

---

Mini-Instruction: Structuring with Precision (10 Minutes)

• Purpose: Teach students how to convert their outline into sections of a coherent, polished essay.
• Activity:
  1. On the board/projector, display an annotated example of a well-structured Paper 2 essay:
     • Introduction with a clear thesis tied to the research question.
     • Body paragraphs that consistently address distinct perspectives with evidence.
     • Well-developed evaluation of perspectives and a powerful conclusion with implications.
  2. Introduce a simplified formula for crafting each body paragraph: Point, Evidence, Explanation, Evaluation (PEEE). Analyze an example:
     • Point: "Economic sanctions complicate global diplomacy more than they resolve conflicts."
     • Evidence: Summarizing a real-world case study or statistic.
     • Explanation: “These sanctions often create internal divisions rather than effectively pressuring governments.”
     • Evaluation: "While the perspective is valid, its effectiveness varies greatly based on the originating country’s political leverage..."

---

Student Activity: Draft Jumpstart (20 Minutes)

• Part 1: Expanding an Outline (10 Minutes)

  • Students will identify one main point from their outline and expand it as a full body paragraph. They will:
    1. Write their point sentence based on a perspective.
    2. Develop their evidence by drawing from pre-researched sources.
    3. Add their explanation and evaluation to analyse credibility or relevance.
  • Walk around and provide focus-point feedback. Encourage clarity and depth where needed.

• Part 2: Peer Editing Activity (10 Minutes)

  • Pair students. Each will exchange and critique their partner’s paragraph using colored pens. They will:
    1. Underline the thesis sentence.
    2. Circle where they see evidence and note its effectiveness.
    3. Use sticky notes to suggest stronger explanations for analysis.

Tip: Offer an example on the smartboard to model respectful peer critique.

---

Wrap-Up: Crafting Cohesion (10 Minutes)

• Purpose: Teach students to link paragraphs for logical flow and consistency.
• Activity:
  1. Ask students: "What happens when paragraph transitions are unclear?" Use a short, disconnected example to demonstrate the issue (e.g., abrupt topic shifts).
  2. Teach students transitional phrases (e.g., "While [Perspective A] explains X, [Perspective B] poses critical challenges by..."). Provide a 1-minute on-the-spot practice challenge.
  3. Have students revisit their drafted paragraph and develop a “next paragraph hook.”

---

Assessment Criteria

Success in this lesson will be defined by:

• Quality of Work: Students’ ability to expand a detailed paragraph with adequate evidence, explanation, and evaluation.
• Engagement: Active participation in peer editing and reflective discussions.
• Reflection: Students’ ability to articulate the purpose of structure and transitions.

---

Homework

1. Draft Development: Based on feedback from today’s lesson, convert two more outline points into full body paragraphs.
2. Self-Evaluation: Use the AICE Paper 2 checklist to evaluate one completed paragraph before the next class.

---

Teacher Reflection

This AICE-aligned strategy allows students to practice higher-order thinking (analysis and evaluation) while strengthening writing skills in a collaborative environment. For future lessons, consider expanding on feedback techniques or providing genre-specific examples.