Understanding Discipline Choices

Grade Level & Curriculum Alignment

Grade Level: 7th Grade
Subject Area: Health Education
Curriculum Area: Mental and Emotional Health (aligned with the National Health Education Standards - NHES, focusing on Standard 4: "Students will demonstrate the ability to use interpersonal communication skills...to enhance health and avoid or reduce health risks.")

---

Lesson Outcome

By the end of this 35-minute lesson, students will:

1. Identify what is considered “violent discipline” (e.g., spanking, yelling, berating).
2. Understand the short-term and long-term harmful effects of using violent discipline on young children.
3. Explore alternative positive discipline strategies to promote healthy childhood development.
4. Practice advocating for non-violent approaches to discipline, using effective communication skills.

---

Materials Needed

• Whiteboard/Chalkboard
• Markers/Chalk
• Small slips of paper for “roleplay scenarios” (pre-written)
• Chart paper for group activity
• “Effects of Discipline” visual aid poster (can be pre-designed or hand-drawn)
• Handout on Positive Discipline Techniques (to take home)

---

Lesson Plan

1. Engagement (5 Minutes)

• Objective: Introduce the topic in a relatable, non-judgmental way.
• Activity: Start with a question: “How do you feel if someone yells at you for doing something wrong?”
  • Give students 1 minute to jot down answers quietly in their notebooks.
  • Facilitate a 2-minute sharing session where volunteers read their answers aloud. Emphasize shared feelings, such as fear, sadness, or anger.
  • Transition: “Now imagine you’re a 4-year-old being punished this way. Today, we’ll explore how violent discipline affects young children and what families can do differently.”

---

2. Explore (10 Minutes)

• Objective: Build understanding of what violent discipline is and why it’s harmful.

Interactive Mini-Lecture (4 Minutes):

Write the following terms on the board:

1. Spanking
2. Yelling/Screaming
3. Humiliation/Berating

Define and give examples of each one briefly. Use age-appropriate scenarios, such as:
"Imagine a toddler spills juice by mistake, and an adult yells at them or spanks them. How do you think this affects the child?”

Effects of Violent Discipline (3 Minutes):

Present key points on the whiteboard or a poster:

• Short-Term Effects: Fear, confusion, loss of trust, and sadness.
• Long-Term Effects: Aggression, low self-esteem, anxiety, difficulty trusting others, and learning problems.

Quick Group Brainstorm (3 Minutes):

Ask: “Why do you think some adults use violent discipline? Do they have other options?”

• Write student responses on the board to affirm participation (e.g., frustration, habit, cultural beliefs).

---

3. Explain Alternatives (8 Minutes)

• Objective: Teach positive, non-violent discipline strategies.

Teach 3 Key Strategies (4 Minutes):

1. Time-Ins Instead of Time-Outs

   • Encourage caregivers to sit with the child during discipline to understand their emotions.

2. Positive Reinforcement

   • Focus on praising good behavior instead of punishing bad behavior.

3. Clear Rules & Consequences

   • Encourage consistent limits and explain why rules exist without resorting to yelling.

Roleplay Activity (4 Minutes):

• Hand out 5 pre-written roleplay scenarios (one for each group of 5 students). Examples:

  • “A child throws a toy at their sibling.”
  • “A toddler refuses to eat dinner.”

• Ask students in their groups to come up with a positive response to the situation using one of the strategies discussed.

• Have one group demonstrate their roleplay, followed by a short commentary about their choice.

---

4. Empowerment & Advocacy (10 Minutes)

• Objective: Equip students to communicate with empathy and advocate for healthier child treatment.

Activity: "Dear Adult..." (6 Minutes)

Students will write a short, anonymous “Dear Adult” letter to an adult in their life. In this letter, they will:

1. Briefly describe why violent discipline is harmful (“When grownups yell or spank, it can make kids feel scared or sad for a long time.”)
2. Suggest one positive discipline strategy they’ve learned.
   • Collect these at the end for review/feedback (teachers can mail them home if appropriate).

Class Discussion (4 Minutes):

Ask students, “If you saw someone using violent discipline in real life, how could you respectfully speak up or help?”
Guide them towards ideas like confiding in a trusted adult or offering gentle suggestions instead of accusations.

---

Closure & Reflection (2 Minutes)

• Revisit the initial question: “How would you feel if someone yelled at you for doing something wrong?”
• Thank the class for exploring such an important issue and remind them:
  “Even though we’re kids now, we can still set an example for the future. When we grow up, we can choose better ways to help kids learn and grow.”
• Hand out the “Positive Discipline Techniques” sheet as a takeaway resource.

---

Assessment

• Participation in discussions and the group roleplay.
• Completion of the “Dear Adult” letter.
• Observation of respectful communication skills during class sharing and brainstorming.

---

Teacher Notes

• Approach the topic with sensitivity and avoid condemning specific adult behaviors. Focus on education, not blame.
• For diverse classrooms, be mindful that some students’ families may have cultural or religious norms around discipline. Be empathetic and inclusive in addressing various perspectives.