Comparing Texts

Year Levels

Year 1 to Year 3

Duration

60 minutes

Class Size

6 students

Unit Context

Lesson 5 of 10 in the unit "Exploring Information Texts"

Lesson Description

Students will compare two informational texts on the same topic through a guided, hands-on activity. They will create a Venn diagram to visually outline the similarities and differences between the texts, developing early comprehension, analytical and comparison skills foundational to information literacy.

---

Australian Curriculum Alignment

Content Descriptions: English (Years 1-3)

• ACELY1661 (Year 1) Recognise that texts contain different types of information (e.g., stories and information texts) and use features of texts (e.g., title and pictures) to locate information.

• ACELY1670 (Year 1) Identify some differences between imaginative and informative texts.

• ACELY1776 (Year 2) Use comprehension strategies to understand and discuss texts listened to, shared and encountered independently.

• ACELY1780 (Year 3) Discuss how depictions of characters in print, sound and images reflect the contexts in which they were created.

• ACELY1781 (Year 3) Identify the main purpose of a text, and explain how the text features help to achieve this purpose.

• ACELY1782 (Year 3) Compare and contrast information within and between texts on the same topic.

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

• Identify key facts and details in two informational texts on the same topic.

• Use text features like headings, images, and captions to find information.

• Compare and contrast information, recognising similarities and differences between texts.

• Create a simple Venn diagram to visually organise these comparisons.

---

Resources Needed

• Two simple informational texts on the same topic (e.g., animals, weather, plants) - print or digital copies suitable and engaging for Years 1 to 3.

• Whiteboard or chart paper.

• Large printed Venn diagram template or individual worksheets with a Venn diagram.

• Coloured markers or pencils.

• Dyslexia-friendly versions of texts (e.g., Arial or OpenDyslexic font, coloured overlays, simplified layout).

• Visual aids such as pictures or videos related to the texts' topic.

---

Lesson Activities

1. Introduction (10 minutes)

• Begin by reminding students what informational texts are and their purpose (to teach or inform).

• Show the two chosen texts side-by-side.

• Discuss the topic of the texts, highlighting headings, pictures, and key vocabulary.

• Use dyslexia-friendly reading supports such as reading aloud, summarising key points with clear, simple language, and visual reinforcements.

2. Guided Reading and Discussion (15 minutes)

• Read both texts together or have students read in pairs, encouraging questions and clarifications.

• Stop frequently to discuss key information, highlighting similarities and differences in facts, pictures, or presentation styles.

• Use prompting questions like:

• "What do these texts tell us about the topic?"

• "What do they have in common?"

• "What is different between them?"

• "How do the pictures help us understand the topic?"

3. Hands-on Venn Diagram Activity (25 minutes)

• Introduce the Venn diagram as a tool to compare and contrast.

• Show the large Venn diagram example on the board/chart.

• As a class, start placing shared facts and differences in appropriate circles.

• Then, have students work individually or in pairs to complete their own Venn diagrams comparing the texts.

• Provide sentence starters to support diverse learners such as:

• "Both texts tell us about …"

• "This text says …, but the other says …"

• For dyslexic students, provide sentence frames with larger font and use colour coding.

4. Sharing and Reflection (10 minutes)

• Invite students to share their Venn diagrams with the class, pointing out one similarity and one difference they found most interesting.

• Facilitate a brief discussion on how comparing texts helps us learn better and think critically.

---

Differentiation Strategies

• For diverse learners / EALD students:

• Provide simplified texts with pictures.

• Use oral reading and interactive reading aloud.

• Use graphic organisers with visuals.

• For students with dyslexia:

• Provide dyslexia-friendly texts with clear fonts, spacing, and overlays.

• Allow oral or pictorial responses to comparisons.

• Offer assistive technology for reading support if available.

• For advanced learners:

• Encourage identifying author’s purpose or text structure differences.

• Have students find additional sources on the same topic to add to the Venn diagram.

• Prompt them to write a short explanation or report on what they learned from comparing the texts.

---

Assessment Strategies

• Observe student participation in discussion and guided reading for comprehension.

• Review completed Venn diagrams for understanding of similarities and differences.

• Listen to student explanations in sharing time to assess their ability to articulate text comparisons.

• Extend assessment through optional written reflection or drawing about the topic comparing the two texts.

---

Reflection and Teacher Notes

• Ensure pacing suits students’ reading levels, adjusting the time for group or individual reading as necessary.

• Use real-world topics tied to students’ interests for higher engagement.

• Technology can be included by using tablets or interactive whiteboards for text display and diagram creation.

• Reinforce the importance of asking questions and looking carefully at texts to understand information fully.

---

This lesson plan meets the requirements of the Australian Curriculum (v9) for English by focusing on comparing informational texts and using comprehension strategies appropriate to Year 1 to 3 students, specifically addressing content descriptions related to text comparison and comprehension strategies.