Unit #2

Lesson Plan Title: Ethical Implications of Key WWII Figures (Lesson 5 of 6)

Curriculum Area and Level

Curriculum Area: History
Level: Year 8-9

Duration

Total Time: 60 minutes
Class Size: 3 students

Learning Objectives

1. To understand the roles of Josef Mengele and Martin Bormann in WWII.
2. To examine the moral and ethical implications of their actions.
3. To develop critical thinking and ethical reasoning skills.

Materials Needed

• Whiteboard and markers
• Printed handouts with information on Josef Mengele and Martin Bormann
• Notebooks for student reflections
• Video clip on Josef Mengele’s experiments (pre-screened for appropriateness)
• Case study printouts for group discussion
• Ethics Debate Cards

Lesson Structure

Introduction (10 minutes)

1. Recap: Briefly review the previous lesson (Lesson 4), highlighting key points about other Nazi figures and their roles.
2. Lesson Objectives: Outline today’s objectives. Explain that today's lesson will focus on Josef Mengele and Martin Bormann.

Background Information (10 minutes)

1. Josef Mengele: Provide a brief biography. Discuss his role at Auschwitz and his experiments on twins.
   • Key Points to Cover:
     • Mengele’s education and joining the Nazi Party
     • His work at Auschwitz
     • Specific examples of experiments on twins (with sensitivity to the age group)
2. Martin Bormann: Provide a brief biography. Discuss his role as Hitler’s Secretary.
   • Key Points to Cover:
     • Bormann’s rise in the Nazi hierarchy
     • His responsibilities and influence on Hitler
     • Actions taken towards the end of the war and his disappearance

Moral and Ethical Implications (15 minutes)

1. Class Discussion:
   • Lead a discussion on the ethical implications of Mengele's experiments. What made his actions unethical?
   • Discuss Bormann’s role and how he facilitated Nazi atrocities.
2. Guiding Questions:
   • Mengele: Why were Mengele’s experiments considered unethical and immoral?
   • Bormann: How did Bormann's position enable Hitler’s policies? What are the moral responsibilities of someone in his position?

Group Activity (15 minutes)

1. Case Studies:
   • Divide the students into three groups of one. Provide each with a case study related to Mengele or Bormann.
   • Instructions: Students read their case study and discuss the ethical implications. Use provided questions to guide their discussion.
2. Reflection:
   • After discussing, have each student write a brief reflection on what they learned, focusing on the ethics involved.

Ethics Debate (10 minutes)

1. Set Up:
   • Each student selects a card from the "Ethics Debate Cards" with statements related to Mengele and Bormann.
   • Examples include: "Mengele's actions were justified by his pursuit of scientific knowledge" or "Bormann was just following orders and shouldn’t be held responsible."
2. Debate:
   • Allow students to present their arguments for or against the statements on their cards.
   • Encourage respectful debate and guide them to consider multiple perspectives.

Conclusion (5 minutes)

1. Summary: Recap the main points discussed during the lesson.
2. Homework: Have students write an essay of 200-300 words on one ethical question discussed in class. They should include historical facts and personal reflection.

Assessment

• Evaluate students’ participation in discussions and their reflections.
• Assess the quality and depth of their written homework essays.

---

End of Lesson 5

This lesson aims to engage students in critical thinking and ethical reasoning, anchored in historical facts about controversial WWII figures. It should help them better understand the complex interplay of power, responsibility, and morality.