Battle of Hastings Evidence

Goal

Students will develop their historical enquiry skills by analysing various sources related to the Battle of Hastings, evaluating their usefulness and reliability in understanding why William of Normandy succeeded in claiming the English throne in 1066.

National Curriculum Links

• History Key Stage 3 (Year 7) – A study of an aspect or theme in British history that extends pupils’ chronological knowledge beyond 1066
• Develop historical enquiry skills by using relevant historical terms, evaluating sources, and constructing balanced arguments.
• Understand social, cultural, and political diversity of past societies.

Learning Objectives

By the end of the lesson, students will be able to:

1. Analyse primary and secondary sources related to the Battle of Hastings to understand different perspectives.
2. Evaluate the usefulness and limitations of sources for establishing historical facts.
3. Explain how source evidence supports the reasons behind William’s victory and claim to the English throne.

Success Criteria

• Students can identify the type of source (primary/secondary).
• Students use evidence from at least two different sources to explain historical claims.
• Students provide reasoned judgements about a source’s reliability and bias.
• Students confidently link source evidence to the wider historical narrative of 1066.

---

Lesson Structure (50 minutes)

1. Starter (5 minutes)

Activity: Quick Recall Quiz

• Recap the competing claims to the English throne in 1066 (Harold Godwinson, William of Normandy, Harald Hardrada).
• Use mini whiteboards for students to write answers to three quick questions to activate prior knowledge.

2. Introduction to Source Analysis (10 minutes)

• Explain briefly the difference between primary and secondary sources with examples (e.g., Bayeux Tapestry vs. a modern history book summary).
• Present the learning goal and success criteria.
• Introduce the idea of bias and reliability — why does it matter in historical enquiry?

3. Main Activity: Group Source Analysis (25 minutes)

• Divide students into four groups (3 students per group).
• Provide each group with a different source related to the Battle of Hastings. Suggested sources:

1. Excerpt from the Bayeux Tapestry (image and description)
2. William of Poitiers’ contemporary account (translated extract)
3. A modern historian’s interpretation (secondary source summary)
4. An Anglo-Saxon Chronicle extract regarding Harold’s coronation and battle.

Tasks:

• Identify the source type and origin.
• Highlight what the source tells us about why William won.
• Discuss possible bias or limitations (e.g., Norman perspective for William of Poitiers).
• Write a brief paragraph concluding the source’s value for understanding the Battle of Hastings.

4. Plenary: Class Discussion and Reflection (10 minutes)

• Each group presents their source’s key points and evaluation to the class.
• Teacher facilitates discussion comparing sources and synthesises how combining evidence gives a fuller picture.
• Highlight how historians weigh different evidence to form explanations.
• End with a prompt question: “If you had to explain why William won, which source would you trust most and why?”

---

Assessment

Formative assessment through observation of group work, questioning during plenary, and students’ analysed source paragraphs. Check for evidence of critical thinking and use of historical terminology such as bias, reliability, and evidence.

---

Extension Activities for Advanced Learners

• Create their own interview scripted as a medieval chronicler and a Norman soldier discussing the battle’s outcome, citing contemporary sources.
• Compare two contrasting sources (e.g., Anglo-Saxon vs Norman accounts) and write a balanced argument on the most persuasive explanation of the victory.
• Investigate the impact of the Battle of Hastings on England’s political and social structures post-1066, making connections to the Norman Conquest’s legacy.

---

Resources Required

• Printed copies or projections of source extracts and images, including a clear image of the Bayeux Tapestry’s relevant panel.
• Whiteboards and pens for starter quiz.
• Worksheets guiding source analysis prompts.
• Pens, paper for notes.

---

This lesson plan encourages critical thinking and historical enquiry aligned to the national curriculum, addressing both content knowledge and vital source evaluation skills tailored for year 7 learners.