Brainstorming Arguments

Overview

In this 60-minute lesson, Year 3 students will collaboratively brainstorm and organise their arguments to persuade others to keep wild areas on a farm. Using graphic organisers, pupils will categorise their ideas into reasons, supporting evidence, and emotional appeals. This activity prioritises speaking and listening, critical thinking, and planning skills, aligning with the National Curriculum for England’s focus on developing writing composition and spoken language.

---

National Curriculum Links

English – Writing (Years 3 and 4)

• Pupils should be taught to:
  • Plan their writing by discussing and recording ideas
  • Use expanded noun phrases to add description and specification
  • Use imperative verbs and persuasive language features
  • Organise ideas around a theme

English – Spoken Language (Years 3 and 4)

• Pupils should be taught to:
  • Participate in discussions, presentations, performances, role play, improvisations and debates
  • Ask relevant questions to extend their understanding and build vocabulary
  • Use spoken language to develop understanding through speculating, hypothesising, imagining and exploring ideas

English – Composition (Years 3 and 4)

• Pupils should learn to:
  • Plan their writing by discussing and recording ideas

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of the lesson, pupils will:

• Collaborate with a partner to generate multiple persuasive arguments to keep wild areas on the farm
• Organise their ideas using a graphic organiser into three key categories: reasons, evidence, and emotional appeals
• Use guided questioning to deepen and clarify their arguments
• Explore imaginative ways to express their thoughts visually and verbally

---

Resources

• Large graphic organisers (printed templates or laminated for reuse) with three labelled columns: Reasons | Evidence | Emotional Appeals
• Prompt question cards for guided support
• Whiteboards and markers
• Sticky notes in three different colours
• Images/photos of farms with wild areas
• Clipboards or writing folders
• Pencils, coloured pencils, crayons
• Extension resource packs with short fact sheets or pictures for advanced learners

---

Lesson Structure

1. Starter (10 minutes)

• Engage: Show vivid images of a farm with wild areas versus a farm without them. Ask the class: “What do you notice about these places?”
• Recall: Briefly review what persuasive writing is and introduce the concept of ‘arguments’ as reasons to convince someone.
• Introduce the task: Explain that today they will brainstorm arguments to keep wild areas on a farm in pairs, categorising their ideas.

Visual aid: Use a large example graphic organiser on the board, with a simple argument filled in for each category.

---

2. Guided Pair Brainstorming (25 minutes)

• Set up: Organise pupils into pairs, each with a graphic organiser and sticky notes.
• Step 1: Each pair brainstorms reasons why keeping wild areas on the farm is important. They write one reason per sticky note (use different coloured notes for each category).
• Step 2: Next, they add sticky notes for evidence (facts, examples, descriptions) to support each reason.
• Step 3: Finally, they add emotional appeals – ideas that might make someone feel strongly about keeping the wild areas (e.g., “wild animals need a home”).
• Teacher role: Circulate with prompt cards to ask guided questions such as:
  • “Why do you think that is important?”
  • “Can you think of something that proves your reason?”
  • “How might this make someone feel?”
• Differentiation: For pupils who struggle with writing, allow them to draw pictures symbolising their ideas or use sentence starters on the prompt cards (e.g. “One reason is...”).

---

3. Whole-class Sharing and Discussion (10 minutes)

• Select a few pairs to share their best ideas from each category.
• Ask classmates to comment, agree, or add to those ideas, encouraging respectful listening and constructive feedback.
• Emphasise imaginative and interesting contributions, reinforcing the use of descriptive language and emotional language.

---

4. Extension Activity for Advanced Learners (10 minutes)

• Provide fact sheets or images about lesser-known benefits of wild areas (e.g., benefits for soil health, insects, pollination).
• Challenge advanced learners to research or suggest additional, more complex arguments for their partners or write a short paragraph expanding one of their points.

---

5. Plenary and Assessment (5 minutes)

• Recap the three categories on the graphic organiser and ask reflective questions:
  • “What makes a good reason?”
  • “How does evidence support your reason?”
  • “Why might emotional appeals be powerful in writing?”
• Collect graphic organisers for informal assessment. Look for pupils’ ability to categorise ideas and use relevant supporting details.

---

Differentiation Summary

Learner Type	Strategies
SEN / Additional Support	Use visual aids, sentence starters, allow drawing instead of writing, paired work for scaffolding
EAL learners	Provide vocabulary cards with persuasive language, use visuals, model reasoning orally
Advanced learners	Extension research activity, encouraged extended writing and use of complex vocabulary

---

Reflection and Next Steps

• Use collected graphic organisers to inform next lesson on drafting persuasive letter paragraphs.
• Consider incorporating role-play debates in the following lesson to bring arguments to life.
• Monitor pairing to ensure balanced collaboration and address misconceptions with targeted feedback.

---

This lesson marries hands-on, imaginative learning with the clear development of speaking, listening, and writing skills essential to persuasive writing in line with the National Curriculum for England. The multi-modal approach will engage all learners while supporting individual needs.