Fact and Opinion

Use the following information to create the lesson plan - The Fine Line Between Fact and Fiction

Is That a Fact?

Distinguishing between fact and opinion is a core skill in the arsenal of any aspiring writer.

Imagine that it is your first day on the job as a junior sportswriter for a popular local newspaper and you've landed a big break - the senior sports editor called in sick and the editor sends you to cover the hotly contested final of two local soccer teams, the Spartans and the PK Lions.

You are incredibly excited as the two teams stride onto the field and you hastily jot down notes so you can capture the atmosphere perfectly later in your article.

But you need to be careful. As a sports journalist, your job is to record the facts of the match as accurately as you can and relate them faithfully to your audience. But is it not also true that you were hired for your sporting background, for your absorption with sport both local and international? You want to give your readers your informed opinion but in reporting on the match, you must maintain an objective viewpoint. 1.1 Understanding the Distinction between Fact and Opinion Let's explore an essential concept that forms the foundation of critical thinking and effective communication: the distinction between fact and opinion. Understanding this distinction is crucial as it directly influences the subjectivity and objectivity of our views and arguments. Facts are statements that can be proven or verified through evidence, data, or direct observation. They are objective and do not change based on personal beliefs or preferences. For instance, "The Earth revolves around the Sun" or "Water boils at 100 degrees Celsius at sea level" are factual statements that can be supported by scientific evidence. Opinions reflect personal viewpoints, beliefs, or judgments. They are subjective and can vary from person to person. Opinions are often influenced by factors such as emotions, values, experiences, and cultural backgrounds. For example, statements like "Chocolate ice cream is the best flavour" or "I think the movie was really entertaining" express personal opinions that cannot be objectively proven or disproven. 1.1b Objectivity and subjectivity Objectivity refers to a viewpoint that is unbiased, neutral, and based on verifiable facts. Objective statements are free from personal emotions or opinions. Scientific research, mathematical equations, and historical events often strive for objectivity by relying on evidence and logical reasoning. Subjectivity refers to the personal perspective or interpretation of an individual. It is closely associated with opinions. When discussing subjective matters, people are entitled to hold different viewpoints, and there is often no right or wrong answer.

For instance, in a debate about the best form of exercise, one person may argue for swimming, while another may prefer running. Both opinions are valid from a subjective standpoint, as personal preferences play a significant role.In conclusion, understanding the distinction between fact and opinion is a fundamental aspect of critical thinking. While facts are objective and can be proven, opinions are subjective and reflect personal viewpoints. By recognising this difference, we can navigate discussions and debates with clarity, objectivity, and respect for diverse perspectives. The Effect of Fact and Opinion in Non-Fiction Facts tell us what happened and can be proven true.

Statements of fact are objective as they contain information but do not express what the writer thinks or believes about the topic. If in doubt, ask yourself whether the statement can be proved true. Can it be observed in practice? (i.e. can you see it happen?) Can it be confirmed by witnesses or documentation?You cannot prove an opinion right or wrong as it is based on personal belief and relates to how someone feels about something. People may agree or disagree with an opinion, but they cannot prove or disprove it. Distinguishing between fact and fiction

As mentioned earlier, writers may tend towards a sprinkling of opinion to spice up the facts of a case and sometimes it is difficult to find the truth amidst a writer's preferences and biases. Luckily, certain words and sentence fragments act as helpful clues to assist us in identifying whether statements are fact-based or opinion-based.

The table below contains examples of sentence fragments that contain the signal words and phrases that often precede a statement of fact or opinion.

Lesson Overview

This 60-minute lesson aims to build Year 9 students’ critical literacy skills by helping them confidently distinguish between fact and opinion in non-fiction texts. Inspired by the scenario of a junior sportswriter covering a local soccer match, the lesson develops students’ ability to identify objective reporting versus subjective commentary, an essential skill aligned with the National Curriculum for English (England).

Class size: 12 students
Age: 13–14 years (Year 9)
Subject: English
Key Focus: Distinguishing fact from opinion; understanding objectivity and subjectivity

National Curriculum Links

Reading - Comprehension (KS3 English Programme of Study):

Identify and interpret explicit and implicit information and ideas.
Select and synthesise evidence from different texts.
Distinguish between statements of fact, opinion, and belief.

Writing - Composition (KS3 English Programme of Study):

Use a wide range of vocabulary and sentence structures to inform, describe, and explain clearly.
Develop consistent and appropriate viewpoints in non-fiction writing.

Spoken Language:

Participate in discussions, listening and responding appropriately to others.
Use spoken language to develop understanding through speculating, hypothesising, and exploring ideas.

Learning Objectives

By the end of the lesson, all students will be able to:

Define and explain the difference between fact and opinion.
Identify signal words and phrases that indicate fact or opinion in given texts.
Recognise the importance of objectivity in journalistic writing.
Begin to produce factual and opinion-based sentences, recognising when to maintain neutrality.

Resources

Printed copies of a short text describing the Spartans vs PK Lions soccer match (split into fact and mixed fact/opinion paragraphs). Dyslexia-friendly font version included.
Whiteboard and markers
Fact vs Opinion signal words handout (colour-coded)
Individual mini whiteboards and pens
Lined exercise books
Laptops/tablets (optional, for extension research activity)
Timer

Lesson Plan

Starter (10 minutes)

Engage (Scenario Introduction)
- Tell the scenario: "You are a junior sportswriter sent to cover the local soccer final…"
- Ask: What do you think is important to include when writing a report?
- Introduce the key question: How do we know what is a fact and what is an opinion when reading or writing about an event?
Quick Think-Pair-Share
- Give students 2 minutes to list one fact and one opinion about a recent event they know (related to sport or school).
- Share a few examples aloud and display them on the board.

Main Activities (40 minutes)

Activity 1: Defining Fact and Opinion (10 minutes)

Present and discuss the definitions of fact and opinion as per the National Curriculum’s emphasis on explicit understanding.
Use real-world examples from scientific facts and personal preferences (e.g., "The Earth revolves around the Sun" vs "Chocolate ice cream is the best flavour").
Introduce objectivity and subjectivity linked to critical thinking skills.
Display simple mnemonic: FACT = Can be Checked, OPINION = Personal Thought

Activity 2: Text Analysis – Spartans vs PK Lions Match (20 minutes)

Distribute the reading text with clearly marked paragraphs containing facts, opinions, and mixed sentences.
In pairs, students colour-code sentences on the handout or annotated sheet:
- Green for Facts
- Yellow for Opinions
Encourage use of the signal words list to guide their judgements (e.g., "clearly", "in my view", "undoubtedly", "according to").
Whole-class discussion: Share answers, clarifying any misconceptions.

Activity 3: Writing Task – Objective and Subjective Sentences (10 minutes)

Individually, students write two sentences about the match:
- One objective fact-based sentence.
- One subjective opinion-based sentence.
Encourage use of signal phrases from the lesson. Peers use mini whiteboards to signal if they think the sentence is fact or opinion.

Plenary (10 minutes)

Reflective group discussion: "Why is distinguishing fact and opinion important in journalism and everyday life?"
Recap the main learning points.
Quick quiz: The teacher reads out 5 statements (some facts, some opinions). Students show thumbs up/down for fact/opinion.

Differentiation Strategies

Learner Need	Approach
Dyslexic Students	Provide dyslexia-friendly versions of texts (clear font, spacing). Use colour-coded signal word handouts. Verbal explanations emphasised. Allow use of laptops/tablets for text-to-speech.
EAL Learners	Pre-teach key vocabulary (fact, opinion, objective, subjective). Pair with a supportive peer. Use visual aids and sentence starters.
Lower Prior Attainment	Extra worked examples in pairs. Provide sentence frames for writing activity. Use mini whiteboards for formative feedback and practice prior to written work.
Higher Prior Attainment	Extension: Research a recent sports article from a UK newspaper online, identify fact and opinion, then rewrite a paragraph to improve objectivity. Present findings to the class or via a short oral presentation.

Assessment and Evaluation

Formative:

Observation of pair and group discussions to assess conceptual understanding.
Colour-coding exercise to identify fact/opinion accuracy.
Mini whiteboard responses during writing activity and plenary quiz for immediate feedback.

Summative:

Written sentences demonstrating understanding of fact and opinion distinctions marked with reference to clarity and correct use of signal phrases.

Additional Notes for Teachers

Emphasise that fact and opinion both have value, but understanding their boundaries helps us to respect different viewpoints while engaging critically with information.
Use lively, relatable sports context to boost engagement.
Scaffold instructions carefully and monitor for misconceptions about facts being “wrong” if someone disagrees.
Encourage respectful language when discussing opinions to model good classroom culture.
For increased challenge or homework, students can track a week's news coverage of a similar event and annotate fact/opinion sentences independently.

This lesson exemplifies the National Curriculum’s commitment to building critical literacy, enabling students to navigate a complex information landscape with confidence and integrity.

Create Your Own AI Lesson Plan

Join thousands of teachers using Kuraplan AI to create personalized lesson plans that align with Aligned with National Curriculum for England in minutes, not hours.

AI-powered lesson creation

Curriculum-aligned content

Ready in minutes

Created with Kuraplan AI

Generated using gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14

🌟 Trusted by 1000+ Schools

Join educators across United Kingdom

Teaching Instructions