Tudor Religious Conflict

Overview

This 50-minute lesson for Year 8 students (ages 12–13) explores Mary Tudor’s attempts to restore Catholicism in England. It directly links to the National Curriculum for History (England, KS3) by developing pupils’ ability to comprehend and analyse historical sources, understand cause and consequence, and make informed judgements.

---

National Curriculum Links

History Programme of Study: Key Stage 3 (Years 7–9)

• Pupils should be taught to:
  • Understand the characteristic features of the period studied and how these relate to other periods.
  • Analyse and explain links and effects of events and the impact of individuals.
  • Use a range of sources to gain increasingly complex understanding of historical events.
  • Develop historical interpretations and reach supported conclusions.

Specifically:

• The development of Church, state and society in Britain 1509–1745, including the English Reformation under Henry VIII and its impact on religion, society and government.

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of the lesson, pupils will:

1. Comprehend and extract key information from a differentiated worksheet about Mary Tudor’s reign and her religious policies.
2. Analyse evidence and statements to evaluate Mary’s likelihood of restoring Catholicism.
3. Use key vocabulary relating to martyrdom and religious sympathy accurately in discussion and written work.

---

Key Vocabulary & Introduction

• Sympathise – introduced discretely at the start, teacher models how people at the time might feel sympathy for martyrs or persecutors.
• Martyrs – introduced with clear explanation and historical context, linking to Hooper and Ridley who were burned for their Protestant beliefs.

Teacher to model pronunciation and context by sharing simplified examples and then showing usage in key sources.

---

Lesson Structure

Starter (10 minutes)

• Activity: Show a 2-minute film clip depicting the burning of Bishops Hooper and Ridley during Mary I’s reign (fictional or historically representative animation/clip).
• Discussion prompt: “What are your feelings watching this? Would executing people this way help Mary achieve her goal of making England Catholic again?”
• Pupils briefly share their reactions verbally to stimulate empathy and critical thinking.

---

Main (30 minutes)

Step 1 – Interactive PowerPoint & Group Activity (15 minutes)

• Present a PowerPoint with statements about Mary’s reign such as:
  • “Mary executed over 280 Protestants.”
  • “Many people secretly continued Protestant worship.”
  • “Mary married Philip II of Spain to strengthen Catholic ties.”
  • “Some Catholic nobles opposed Mary’s harsh methods.”
• Pupils discuss where each statement fits on a “fence diagram” labelled:
  • Likely to help restore Catholicism (Yes side)
  • Unlikely to help restore Catholicism (No side)

Step 2 – Individual/Pair Work (15 minutes)

• Pupils cut out printed statements (differentiated versions depending on ability) from worksheet and glue onto a blank "fence" worksheet.
• They annotate briefly why they placed each statement on either side, linking to historical causes and consequences. This supports comprehension and analysis.

---

Plenary (10 minutes)

Guided Class Discussion:

• Use a visual summary board to reflect on the question: “Was Mary Tudor likely to be successful at making England Catholic again?”
• Encourage pupils to express reasoned opinions: “Yes in the short term because of severe punishments and marriage alliances, but no in the long term because of resistance and Elizabeth I’s succession.”
• Reinforce use of vocabulary words ‘sympathise’ and ‘martyrs’ in their explanations.

---

Assessment & Feedback

• Formative assessment through observation of group discussions and placement of statements on fence diagram.
• Collect pupils’ annotated worksheets for quick assessment of understanding and reasoning skills.
• Provide verbal feedback during plenary, highlighting effective use of key vocabulary and evidence-based conclusions.

---

Differentiation

• Scaffolded worksheets with simpler or more complex language for pupils with different reading abilities.
• Extension: Challenge higher-achieving pupils to write a short paragraph explaining why using terror as a tactic to enforce religion may fail.

---

Resources

• Film clip of Hooper and Ridley burning (teacher-prepared)
• Interactive PowerPoint with statements and accompanying images
• Worksheet with statements cut-outs and blank fence template
• Whiteboard or display for plenary summary

---

Teacher Reflection Suggestions

• Did pupils engage emotionally and critically with the film clip starter?
• Were pupils able to justify their placement of statements with historical reasoning?
• How confidently did pupils use the new vocabulary in their discussion?
• Adjust future lessons to incorporate more scaffolded support or opportunities for deeper enquiry based on class response.

---

By combining emotive stimulus with analysis of contrasting evidence, this lesson develops students’ historical empathy and analytical skills in line with the National Curriculum’s requirements. The ‘fence diagram’ active learning encourages clear judgement formation in an accessible way for Year 8 learners.