Comparing Great Ideas

Curriculum Area and Level

Curriculum Area: English Language Arts (ELA)
Grade Level: 6th Grade (Aligned with Common Core Standards CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.6.3 and CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.6.2)

---

Lesson 1: Compare and Contrast Key Concepts

Lesson Duration:

30 minutes

---

Objectives for Lesson 1

By the end of this lesson, students will:

1. Identify at least three similarities and three differences between two narrators in short passages.
2. Use appropriate comparative language (e.g., "similarly," "however," "in contrast") in group discussions and written tasks.
3. Understand how to organize their observations in a Venn diagram.
4. Create structured notes about the comparison/contrast activity.

---

Materials Needed

• Two short contrasting narrative passages (e.g., excerpts from a diary entry and a newspaper report on the same event).
• Whiteboard or smartboard for guiding a class-created Venn diagram.
• Handouts with partially completed Venn diagrams and sentence starters for comparative language support.
• Writing journals for reflection.

---

Lesson Outline

Introduction (5 minutes)

1. Activate Prior Knowledge:
   • Start with an engaging question: “How would you talk about two different ice cream flavors you like?” Quickly elicit responses about similarities and differences.
   • Explain that today we will be comparing the way two narrators describe the same event.
2. Goal Setting:
   • Share today’s objectives: "We’ll identify similarities and differences in the narrators’ perspectives, organize our thoughts in a Venn diagram, and use strong comparative language to explain our ideas."

---

Guided Group Activity (15 minutes)

1. Step 1: Quick Reading (5 Minutes)

   • Distribute the two short narrative passages. For example:
     • Passage 1: A diary entry of a child describing a snow day.
     • Passage 2: A newspaper report about a snowstorm in the same town.
   • Students take turns reading aloud with partners.

2. Step 2: Small-Group Collaboration (10 Minutes)

   • Ask students to work in groups of 4. Each group answers the following questions:
     • What are the key similarities between the two narrators?
     • How do the narrators’ styles (diary vs. newspaper) affect the way they describe the event?
   • Groups use Venn Diagrams (provided as handouts) to organize their points.
   • Encourage students to incorporate comparative words like "both," "similarly," "in contrast," "on the other hand," and "while."
   • After completing the activity, students nominate one "reporter" to share 2 similarities and 2 differences with the whole class.

---

Wrap-Up (5 minutes)

1. Discussion: Briefly ask, "How did organizing your thoughts in the Venn diagram help you?"
2. Reflection: In their writing journals, students complete the sentence starters:
   • The narrators are similar because...
   • One main difference I noticed was...
   • I find comparing and contrasting important because...

---

Assessment for Lesson 1:

• Check Venn diagram completion for accuracy and specific details.
• Evaluate speaking contributions for use of comparative language, ensuring alignment with language rubric.

---

Lesson 2: Comparative Writing Practice

Lesson Duration:

30 minutes

---

Objectives for Lesson 2

By the end of this lesson, students will:

1. Write a structured comparative paragraph highlighting key similarities and differences between two texts.
2. Demonstrate proper use of comparative vocabulary in their writing.
3. Create clear topic sentences based on their Venn diagram observations.
4. Edit their writing for clarity and organization.

---

Materials Needed

• Completed Venn diagrams from previous lesson.
• Writing templates for paragraph drafting (includes prompts for topic, supporting, and concluding sentences).
• "Word Bank" chart on the whiteboard with comparative phrases.
• Colored markers or pencils.

---

Lesson Outline

Introduction (5 minutes)

1. Review Key Concepts:
   • Quickly refer to the Venn diagrams created in the previous lesson.
   • Write these comparative phrases on the board: “similarly,” “however,” “in contrast,” “on the other hand.” Ask the class: “Can you use one of these words right now to compare the narrators?”
2. Goal Setting:
   • Share today’s outcome: "We’ll turn our notes into a professional paragraph comparing the two narrators.”

---

Independent Writing Time (15 minutes)

1. Draft Together:

   • Model the process by creating a comparative paragraph introduction with the class:
     "Both the diary entry and newspaper article describe a snowstorm, but they do so in very different ways."
   • Prompt students to write their own opening sentence individually, using their Venn diagrams. Check a few students' sentences aloud for feedback.

2. Expand on Observations:

   • Using their Venn diagrams, students write 2-3 supporting sentences. Remind them to include:
     • At least one similarity.
     • At least one difference.
   • Suggest they underline or circle their comparative words in their draft using colored markers.

---

Peer Editing and Sharing (10 minutes)

1. Partner Editing:
   • Students swap papers with a partner and check each other’s work for comparative language and clarity.
   • Partners use a rubric (provided by teacher) to check for:
     • A clear opening and closing sentence.
     • Use of comparative language.
     • At least one similarity and one difference.
2. Mini Celebrations:
   • After edits, ask a few students to share their completed paragraphs with the class.

---

Wrap-Up (Final 3 minutes)

• Close the lesson by reflecting: "How does comparing and contrasting help us in real life?" Discuss briefly (e.g., shopping decisions, choosing books to read).

---

Assessment for Lesson 2:

• Formative: Monitor paragraph drafts for use of Venn diagram ideas and comparative phrases.
• Summative: Evaluate completed paragraphs using a rubric:
  • Clear topic and transition sentences.
  • Logical organization of information.
  • Accurate use of comparative words.

---

Differentiation Opportunities

• Advanced Learners: Challenge them to include more complex sentence structures (e.g., compound-complex sentences).
• EL Students: Provide sentence frames for support: "Both narrators describe..."; "Unlike the diary, the newspaper focuses on..."
• Struggling Writers: Pair with a partner for more brainstorming time and guidance.

---

Teacher Reflection Prompt

• Did all students actively participate in the collaborative diagram process?
• Were students confident using comparative language in writing by the end of Lesson 2?
• What adjustments can be made in future lessons?