Unit

Voices of Freedom: Harriet Tubman (Lesson 2 of 3)

Duration

45 minutes

Class Size

20 Students

---

Cambridge International Curriculum Alignment

• Stage: Cambridge Lower Secondary (equivalent to US Grade 6)
• Subject: English as a Second Language (English Language)
• Curriculum Framework: Cambridge Lower Secondary English Language (typically for learners aged 11-14)
• Key Competencies Addressed:
  • Reading comprehension and analysis (Learning Objective 3.1)
  • Understanding author’s purpose and point of view (Learning Objective 3.3)
  • Comparing and contrasting texts (Learning Objective 3.6)
  • Critical thinking about narrative impact (Learning Objective 3.7)

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

1. Identify and compare the perspectives presented in different texts about slavery.
2. Analyze author purposes and emotional tones within narrative excerpts about Harriet Tubman and other slavery accounts.
3. Organize comparative ideas effectively using graphic organizers.
4. Explain the similarities and differences between the texts, supporting their answers with textual evidence.

---

Materials Needed

• Copies of three short reading excerpts on slavery (including the provided Harriet Tubman excerpt)
• Graphic Organizer Worksheet: Venn Diagram and T-Chart format
• Whiteboard and markers
• Sticky notes
• Student notebooks and pencils

---

Lesson Procedure

1. Introduction (5 minutes)

• Set Context:
  Begin by briefly recapping Lesson 1’s key points about Harriet Tubman and the historical context of slavery.
• Hook:
  Pose the question: “Why do you think different people might describe the experience of slavery differently?”
• Learning Objective Sharing:
  Write the objectives on the board and discuss them aloud, ensuring students understand the focus on comparing perspectives and author purpose.

---

2. Guided Reading and Annotation (15 minutes)

• Reading Activity:
  Distribute three short excerpts from different authors describing slavery, including an excerpt from Harriet Tubman’s life.
  • Text 1: Harriet Tubman excerpt (primary narrative, emotional tone)
  • Text 2: Account from a former slave narrative (e.g., Frederick Douglass-like)
  • Text 3: A historical document (e.g., a letter or newspaper excerpt with a different perspective)
• Silent Reading:
  Students silently read each excerpt.
• Annotation:
  Use sticky notes for students to mark passages that show the author’s feelings, purpose, and any strong emotions expressed.

---

3. Group Discussion & Graphic Organizer Completion (15 minutes)

• Pair Work:
  Students form pairs to discuss initial thoughts on each text’s perspective and purpose.
• Graphic Organizer:
  Provide a graphic organizer with two parts:
  • Venn Diagram for comparing two texts
  • T-chart for noting different author purposes and emotional impact for each text
• Instruction:
  Students fill out the graphic organizer, highlighting similarities and differences in perspectives.
• Teacher Monitoring:
  Circulate, prompting deeper thinking with questions like:
  • “What emotions do you feel from this author’s words?”
  • “What might be the author's intention in telling this story this way?”

---

4. Whole-Class Sharing and Reflection (8 minutes)

• Sharing:
  Invite pairs to share their findings, focusing on one key similarity and one key difference they discovered. Write some examples on the board.
• Reflection Prompt:
  Ask: “How do different perspectives help us understand more about the history of slavery?”
• Brief Writing:
  Have students spend 3 minutes writing a short paragraph answering this reflection question in their notebooks, citing examples from the texts.

---

5. Assessment and Closure (2 minutes)

• Formative Assessment:
  Collect the graphic organizers to informally assess comprehension and ability to compare perspectives.
• Homework Preview/Reminder:
  Explain that in Lesson 3, students will create a short presentation or creative response about Harriet Tubman's voice in these stories.

---

Differentiation and Support

• For EAL or Lower-Reading Students:
  Pre-highlight key words in texts, provide vocabulary sheets, and offer sentence starters for graphic organizer and reflection writing.
• For Advanced Students:
  Challenge them to analyze the historical context influencing each author’s perspective and consider bias.
• Visual Learners:
  Graphic organizers and sticky notes aid visual engagement.
• Auditory Learners:
  Oral sharing during pair and whole-class discussions reinforces understanding.

---

Teacher Tips - Wowing with AI-Enhanced Ideas

• Use audio recordings of the texts (human voice or AI-read) to cater to auditory learners and increase engagement.
• Utilize tablet or interactive whiteboard software to create digital Venn diagrams live in class for collaborative editing.
• Incorporate emotion analysis by asking students to describe feelings evoked, then use word clouds (generated with simple AI tools outside of class) for class display to visualize collective emotional responses.
• Record short student reflections on tablets (1-minute videos) to promote speaking skills and future peer learning.

---

Summary of Key Time Allocations

Activity	Time (minutes)
Introduction	5
Guided Reading & Annotation	15
Pair Discussion & Graphic Organizer	15
Whole Class Sharing & Reflection	8
Closure & Assessment	2

---

This structured, engaging, and curriculum-aligned lesson plan ensures that 6th grade learners engage deeply and critically with multiple perspectives on slavery, contextualizing Harriet Tubman’s story within a wider historical narrative and developing key Cambridge English competencies in reading and analysis.