Dictators in Ancient Rome

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this 60-minute lesson, Grade 9 students will be able to:

• Explain the concept of dictatorship in the Roman Republic and how it differed from modern dictatorship.
• Identify the powers and temporary role of Roman dictators and distinguish these from other political offices such as consuls.
• Analyze the historical impact and legacy of notable Roman dictators including Julius Caesar.
• Evaluate primary source excerpts regarding Roman dictators and participate in a reasoned debate on their effectiveness and influence.
• Engage in role-playing to understand the political dynamics of the Roman Senate during the appointment of a dictator.
• Express historical perspectives creatively through writing from the viewpoint of a Roman citizen during Julius Caesar’s dictatorship.

Common Core Standards Alignment

• RH.9-10.1: Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources.
• RH.9-10.2: Determine the central ideas or information of a primary or secondary source; provide an accurate summary.
• RH.9-10.6: Compare the point of view of two different authors regarding the same historical event.
• WHST.9-10.1: Write arguments focused on discipline-specific content.
• SL.9-10.1: Initiate and participate effectively in a range of collaborative discussions.

---

Key Vocabulary

• Republic
• Dictator (Roman context)
• Consul
• Imperium
• Senate
• Julius Caesar
• Temporary power
• Historical impact

---

Materials Needed

• Copies of selected primary source excerpts (e.g., Plutarch’s Life of Caesar, Livy’s writings on Roman dictators)
• Whiteboard and markers
• Chart paper and markers for group work
• Printed debate guidelines and roles
• Timer/clock
• Role-play scenario cards for senators
• Writing paper or notebooks for diary entry

---

Lesson Procedure

1. Introduction and Warm-Up (10 minutes)

• Begin with an engaging question: “What comes to mind when you hear the word ‘dictator’?” Collect a few responses.
• Briefly explain the difference between modern dictatorships and the role of dictators in Ancient Rome. Highlight that Roman dictators were appointed temporarily during emergencies with defined legal limits.
• Share learning objectives and key vocabulary to the class.

2. Direct Instruction: The Role and Powers of Roman Dictators (10 minutes)

• Present a concise mini-lecture using the whiteboard to explain:
  • The structure of the Roman Republic government focusing on Consuls vs. Dictators.
  • The circumstances under which a dictator was appointed.
  • Powers held by the dictator (e.g., imperium), typically lasting 6 months.
• Highlight Julius Caesar’s unique role and how his dictatorship differed and contributed to the fall of the Republic.

3. Document Analysis Activity (15 minutes)

• Divide the class into five groups of 5 students each.
• Distribute primary source excerpts about Roman dictators, especially Julius Caesar. Each group analyzes one document focusing on:
  • The author’s perspective and purpose
  • What it reveals about the power and role of dictators
  • Any bias or limitation of the document
• Groups complete a brief graphic organizer to summarize their analysis.

4. Role-Playing Simulation: Senate Debate on Appointing a Dictator (10 minutes)

• Assign roles to students as Roman senators with different viewpoints (e.g., supporters of dictatorship for emergency, opponents fearing loss of Republic).
• Provide scenario cards outlining the situation requiring a dictator’s appointment.
• Facilitate a structured debate where senators present arguments for or against appointing a dictator, using vocabulary and historical context.
• Encourage students to use persuasive language and consider the political tensions of the time.

5. Group Presentations and Class Discussion (10 minutes)

• Each group presents a 2-minute summary of their document analysis focusing on evidence about the dictators’ power and impact.
• Facilitate a whole-class discussion guided by these questions:
  • How did the Roman dictator differ from today’s dictators?
  • Was Julius Caesar’s dictatorship justified or a threat to the Republic? Why?

6. Structured Debate (10 minutes)

• Split the class into two teams:
  • Team A argues Julius Caesar’s dictatorship was necessary for Rome’s stability.
  • Team B argues his dictatorship was harmful and led to the Republic’s end.
• Provide 3 minutes preparation using notes and vocabulary, then 7 minutes for debate (alternate speaking turns).
• Encourage use of evidence from the document analysis and prior discussion.

7. Creative Writing Task: Diary Entry from a Roman Citizen (5 minutes)

• Ask students to write a short diary entry imagining they are a Roman citizen living during Julius Caesar’s dictatorship.
• Prompt them to express their feelings, concerns, or hopes about the political changes and the role of the dictator.
• This task encourages empathy and deeper understanding of historical perspectives.

8. Conclusion and Assessment (5 minutes)

• Prompt students to write a 3-4 sentence exit ticket responding to:
  • “In your own words, explain one major difference between Roman dictators and modern dictators, and why this matters in understanding Ancient Rome’s history.”
• Collect exit tickets for formative assessment.

---

Assessment

• Formative: Group document analysis graphic organizers and presentations demonstrate understanding of primary sources.
• Summative: Exit ticket provides evidence of individual comprehension of the dictator’s role within the Roman Republic and their historical impact.
• Speaking & Listening: Participation and reasoning in the debate and role-play assess students’ oral communication aligned with SL.9-10.1 standards.
• Creative Writing: Diary entries assess students’ ability to synthesize historical knowledge and express perspective in writing.

---

Differentiation and Extensions

• For diverse learners: Provide pre-highlighted documents or guided notes to support reading comprehension. Allow use of sentence starters for debate and diary entry.
• Extension activity: Research and present on the legacy of Julius Caesar in later political systems or comparisons between Ancient Roman dictatorship and other historical dictatorships.
• Use of technology: If available, students can record debate segments or use digital tools to collaboratively annotate primary documents. Students may also type diary entries using word processing tools.

---

End this session by encouraging students to consider how different historical forms of leadership influence modern ideas about power and government.

---