Feedback and Goals

Grade Levels

6-8

Duration

120 minutes

Unit Context

Lesson 19 of 20 in the "Secret Agent STEM Mission" unit

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

• Reflect on their STEM camp experience and articulate personal strengths and growth areas.
• Collaboratively share feedback to enhance group learning environments.
• Develop specific, measurable, and attainable personal STEM learning goals.
• Connect goal-setting with future STEM skills development.
• Understand how continuous STEM learning impacts real-world problem solving.

---

Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) Alignment

• Practices:

  • Obtaining, Evaluating, and Communicating Information (NGSS Practice 8)
  • Engaging in Argument from Evidence (NGSS Practice 7)
  • Developing and Using Models (NGSS Practice 2 - for goal-setting frameworks)

• Crosscutting Concepts:

  • Feedback Mechanisms (Systems and System Models)
  • Stability and Change (Goal setting is part of managing and responding to change)

• Disciplinary Core Ideas:

  • ETS1.A: Defining and Delimiting Engineering Problems – how setting goals helps refine problems and focus efforts

---

Materials Needed

• Feedback journals (notebooks or printed templates)
• Sticky notes (3 colors)
• Markers and pens
• Poster paper or whiteboard
• Timer
• Goal-setting graphic organizers
• STEM career cards (optional for motivation)

---

Lesson Outline

1. Introduction & Warm-up (15 minutes)

• Engage:
  Begin with a quick “STEM Superpowers” circle where each student names one STEM skill or project from camp they feel proud of.

• Purpose:
  Explain that the day will focus on reflecting, sharing feedback, and looking ahead by setting personal goals. Connect this to real scientists and engineers who regularly reflect on their work and adjust their goals.

---

2. Reflective Feedback Journaling (20 minutes)

• Distribute feedback journals.

• Prompt students to write in response to these questions:

  • What was my favorite part of this STEM camp?
  • What challenged me the most?
  • What skills did I improve?
  • What skills do I want to work on more?

• Encourage honesty and specific details.

• Circulate and provide personalized feedback or encouragement.

---

3. Group Feedback Activity: “Feedback Gallery Walk” (30 minutes)

• Setup:
  Arrange three large posters on the walls labeled:

  • What Went Well
  • What Could Be Better
  • Ideas for Future STEM Missions

• Students write one comment or idea per sticky note using different colors for each poster (e.g., green for praise, yellow for suggestions, pink for ideas).

• Students walk around, read, and discuss the comments in small groups, adding new notes or questions.

• After the walk, facilitate a brief whole-class discussion highlighting common themes and interesting ideas.

---

4. Goal-Setting Mini-Lesson (15 minutes)

• Discuss the importance of goal setting in STEM and real-world careers.

• Review the SMART goal framework:

  • Specific
  • Measurable
  • Attainable
  • Relevant
  • Time-bound

• Model creating one SMART goal related to STEM skills (e.g., “I will build a simple circuit at home by next month to improve my understanding of electrical systems”).

---

5. Personal STEM Goal Development (25 minutes)

• Distribute goal-setting graphic organizers.

• Students write 2-3 personal STEM goals using the SMART format.

• Encourage students to consider:

  • Skills they want to develop further from camp
  • New STEM areas they want to explore
  • How they can use these skills beyond camp (school, home projects, clubs)

• Teachers circulate providing feedback, helping refine goals.

---

6. Sharing and Commitment Circle (15 minutes)

• Form a circle for students to share one of their goals.

• Encourage positive peer feedback and ideas for support.

• Optionally, students can partner up as “STEM accountability buddies” to check in on goals after camp.

---

7. Wrap-Up & Future STEM Missions (10 minutes)

• Facilitate a class discussion:

  • How can we continue our STEM missions outside of camp?
  • What resources or strategies might we use (libraries, online platforms, clubs)?

• Provide STEM career cards or anecdotes illustrating lifelong learning in STEM careers.

• End with a motivational message: "Every STEM explorer’s mission is never truly finished – it evolves with every new challenge!"

---

Assessment

• Formative:

  • Quality and depth in feedback journal entries
  • Participation in group feedback and discussion
  • Completion and clarity of SMART goals

• Summative:

  • A brief written reflection (exit ticket) on how personal goals will help continue STEM learning beyond camp.

---

Differentiation Strategies

• Provide sentence starters or word banks for students needing writing support.
• Allow goal-setting conversations in pairs before independent writing.
• Visual organizers for goal planning aid students with executive function challenges.
• Offer extension prompts for accelerated students to include a plan of action for their goals.

---

Teacher Reflection & Notes

• Capture observations about students most engaged with goal-setting and feedback sharing.
• Consider creating a follow-up plan for students to share progress on goals after the unit ends.
• Use student feedback to adjust lesson 20 for a stronger closure or celebration.

---

This plan integrates reflective practice with practical STEM skill-building in alignment with NGSS practices, empowering students to become future-focused, self-regulated learners and problem solvers.