Moral Complexity in Literature

---

Curriculum Area:

English Language Arts (ELA)
Grade Level: 12th Grade
Standards Alignment:

• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.2: Determine two or more themes or central ideas of a text and analyze their development over the course of the text.
• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.11-12.3: Analyze the impact of the author's choices regarding how to develop and relate elements of a story or drama.
• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.11-12.1: Write arguments to support claims, using valid reasoning and evidence.

---

Objective:

By the end of this 120-minute lesson, students will:

1. Analyze the moral complexity of a chosen character in "The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald.
2. Explore how Fitzgerald uses literary devices to make specific characters morally ambiguous.
3. Develop a nuanced thesis statement about morality in the novel for a short structured writing activity.
4. Engage in a group discussion that builds critical analysis and collaboration skills.

---

Materials:

1. Copies of "The Great Gatsby" (students should have completed reading it in advance).
2. Whiteboard and markers.
3. Printed handouts (Character Analysis Chart, Literary Devices Tracker, Quick Essay Scaffold).
4. Sticky notes and colored pens/pencils.
5. Timer (for structured discussion activities).

---

Lesson Outline

1. Warm-Up (15 minutes)

Activity Title: Defining Moral Ambiguity

• Prep: Write "Moral Ambiguity" on the board and provide its definition: a situation in which a character or behavior lacks clear ethical resolution, showing both good and bad sides.
• Whole Class Activity: Facilitate a brainstorming activity. Ask students:
  • What examples of morally ambiguous characters from books, TV, or films can you recall?
  • Why are morally ambiguous characters compelling, and how do they make us feel?
• Interactive Component: Create a two-column chart titled "Appealing Traits vs. Ethical Flaws" and list examples from the discussion.
• Wrap up by connecting it back to The Great Gatsby: "Which characters do you think are morally ambiguous in the novel?"

---

2. Mini-Lecture (15 minutes)

Title: The Art of Moral Ambiguity in The Great Gatsby

• Provide students with background context:
  • How Fitzgerald uses Jay Gatsby and Daisy Buchanan as reflections of ambition, desire, and flawed ethics.
• Highlight three literary devices that create moral ambiguity:
  1. Symbolism (e.g., the green light as hope or unattainable obsession).
  2. Irony (e.g., Gatsby's romantic persistence versus his criminal behavior).
  3. Narrative Perspective (e.g., interpreting the story through Nick, who has his own biases).
• Pose an essential question: "Does Fitzgerald intend for us to admire or critique Gatsby?"

---

3. Group Work (30 minutes)

Activity Title: Character Analysis Workshop

1. Form Groups of 2: Each pair selects either Jay Gatsby, Daisy Buchanan, or Tom Buchanan. Each group receives a Character Analysis Chart to complete.
   • Column 1: Actions/Decisions.
   • Column 2: Positive Traits.
   • Column 3: Flaws/Negative Traits.
   • Column 4: Supporting Quotes from the novel.
2. Example Modeling: Do a brief example as a class using Nick Carraway before students begin their group work.
3. Share Out: Groups briefly present their findings to the class (3 minutes/group).

---

4. Literary Devices Hunt (15 minutes)

Activity Title: Building the Case for Ambiguity

• Distribute Literary Devices Tracker handouts. Students work individually to find quotes from The Great Gatsby that demonstrate symbolism, irony, or Nick's unreliable perspective.
• Use sticky notes to label their findings directly in their book or jot them on the provided worksheets. Encourage them to think about how Fitzgerald’s techniques enhance complexity.
• Challenge: Each student must argue which device most effectively contributes to moral ambiguity in The Great Gatsby.

---

5. Structured Debate (30 minutes)

Activity Title: The Trial of Jay Gatsby

• Setup: Split students into two groups:
  1. Defense Team: Argues that Gatsby is ultimately a good, admirable character.
  2. Prosecution Team: Argues that Gatsby’s flaws overshadow his positive traits.
• Provide guiding questions for their argument prep:
  • What motivates Gatsby’s actions?
  • Do the ends justify the means in his pursuit of love and success?
  • How does Nick's narration impact how we perceive Gatsby?
• Use a timer for structured debate:
  • Opening statements: 3 minutes per side.
  • Rebuttals: 2 minutes per side.
  • Closing statements: 2 minutes per side.
• Conclude with a student vote on where Gatsby stands on the morality spectrum.

---

6. Writing (15 minutes)

Activity Title: Crafting a Thesis on Morality

• Prompt: Distribute a Quick Essay Scaffold worksheet. Students craft a clear and concise thesis statement in response to this prompt:
  • “To what extent does Fitzgerald present Gatsby as a morally ambiguous character, and what is the significance of this ambiguity in the novel?”
• Guide students as they draft 1-2 topic sentences paired with evidence from their notes or earlier activities.

---

7. Wrap-Up and Reflection (15 minutes)

1. Class Discussion: Revisit the essential question: "Does Fitzgerald want us to admire Gatsby or critique him?" Have students share their new perspectives after today’s session.
2. Exit Ticket: On an index card, have students anonymously respond to:
   • “Which activity helped you the most today in understanding moral ambiguity? What is one question you still have about this topic?”

---

Assessment:

Students are assessed on:

1. Group presentations (Character Analysis Charts).
2. Debate participation and understanding of moral ambiguity.
3. Quality of thesis statement and supporting examples produced in the writing activity.

---

Differentiation Strategies:

• Advanced Learners: Encourage deeper exploration of Nick’s reliability and encourage comparative analysis with other morally ambiguous characters in literature or modern media.
• Struggling Learners: Provide pre-identified quotes for the literary devices hunt to scaffold their analysis. Pair them with supportive peers during group work.
• Visual Learners: Use colored sticky notes or annotations to visually code moral traits and literary devices directly in the text.

---

Homework:

Ask students to write a short paragraph expanding on their thesis statement, using at least two pieces of textual evidence. They should also pose one thought-provoking question about morality in The Great Gatsby to be discussed in the next class.