Would YOU Sail?

Grade 7 Social Studies — 60 minutes

---

Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:

• Analyze the key motivations and risks faced by early colonists aboard the Mayflower.
• Evaluate different perspectives to decide whether they would choose to sail on the Mayflower.
• Develop evidence-based arguments supporting their decision using primary and secondary sources.
• Engage in critical group discussions and reflective writing.

---

Standards Alignment

Common Core State Standards for Social Studies, Grade 7:

• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.6-8.1
  • Cite specific textual evidence to support analysis of primary and secondary sources.
• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RH.6-8.2
  • Determine the central ideas or information of a primary or secondary source.
• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.WHST.6-8.1
  • Write arguments focused on discipline-specific content using valid reasoning.
• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.7.1
  • Engage effectively in collaborative discussions with diverse partners on grade 7 topics, expressing ideas clearly with evidence.
• CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.7.4
  • Present claims and findings clearly and with relevant evidence.

---

Materials Needed

• Printed copies of brief primary source extracts (e.g., Mayflower Compact excerpt, Pilgrim letters)
• Risk & Motivation Analysis Worksheet (custom-designed table)
• Index cards with scenarios/risks/motivations
• Whiteboard or large paper for group ideas
• Writing journals or paper for each student
• Colored markers or pencils

---

Lesson Procedure

1. Introduction & Hook (10 minutes)

• Begin by asking students:
  “Imagine you are in 1620. Would you be willing to leave everything behind and sail on the Mayflower? Why or why not?”
• Use think-pair-share: Students jot down thoughts individually (2 min), then discuss in pairs (3 min), then share with the group (5 min).
• Introduce the goal: Evaluate motivations (reasons for sailing) and risks (dangers encountered) using primary and secondary sources.

2. Exploration of Motivations and Risks (15 minutes)

• Distribute short excerpts from primary sources (like the Mayflower Compact) and secondary summaries about Mayflower passengers’ motivations: religious freedom, economic opportunity, adventure.
• Hand out a worksheet with two columns: Motivations and Risks.
• In pairs, students read excerpts and classify motivations and risks on their worksheet, citing evidence from the text.
• Discuss their findings to clarify any misconceptions. Teacher models citing evidence aloud on whiteboard.

3. Hands-On Argument Building Activity (20 minutes)

• Give each student 3 index cards—some labeled with motivations, some with risks, others with “What if?” scenarios (e.g., storms at sea, starvation, relationships with Native Americans).
• Each student selects cards to build their own argument: Would they or would they not sail on the Mayflower?
• Students draft a short persuasive paragraph in their journals using evidence from the readings and their cards.
• Pair-share their arguments and provide peer feedback using a simple rubric: clarity, evidence cited, and reasoning.

4. Group Discussion & Reflection (10 minutes)

• Facilitate a group discussion using these questions:
  • Which motivation do you find most compelling to sail?
  • Which risk made you most hesitant?
  • How does understanding these help us see the challenges early colonists faced?
• Students refine thoughts based on discussion and write a 3-4 sentence reflection in journals.

5. Closure & Assessment (5 minutes)

• Collect worksheets and journals for informal assessment.
• Exit ticket: On a slip of paper, students write "Would YOU sail? Yes or No. One sentence supporting your answer with evidence."

---

Assessment Ideas

• Formative: Observation of pair and group discussions, participation, and completion of analysis worksheet.
• Written: Persuasive paragraph graded with a rubric aligned to CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.WHST.6-8.1 (argument writing with evidence).
• Exit Ticket: Quick check for understanding and application of lesson content.
• Rubric Criteria: Evidence use, reasoning clarity, engagement with source material.

---

Teacher Notes / Extensions

• For deeper engagement, students can act out a short “Mayflower Town Hall” debating whether to embark on the voyage, using their cards as character motivations and risks.
• Incorporate map work if time permits—trace the Mayflower’s route and discuss geographical challenges.
• Connect to modern immigration themes by comparing motivations and risks between early colonists and today’s migrants.
• Adapt the writing task for students who prefer oral presentations.

---

This lesson combines critical thinking, source analysis, hands-on argument construction, and collaborative discussion to bring the motivations and risks of the Mayflower colonists to life. It meets 7th grade Common Core standards in history/social studies literacy and argument writing, providing a rich, immersive experience for homeschool learners.