Social SciencesFreePrintable

Ada's Changing Historical Significance

A free social sciences worksheet ready for your classroom. Open in Kuraplan to grab the print-ready PDF, customize it for your students, or generate a fresh version in seconds.

Download now

Name:Date:

Ada's Changing Historical Significance

Read the evidence cards, then answer the questions. Consider who created each account, what it emphasises, and how values and historical questions can change. Use evidence from the cards in your written answers.

Evidence cards: a changing story

Context: Ada Blackjack (1898–1983) was an Iñupiat woman from Alaska. In 1921, she joined an expedition to Wrangel Island, north of Siberia, as a seamstress and cook. The expedition aimed to claim the island for Canada. After the planned supply ship failed to arrive, four men left the island to seek help. They did not return. Ada remained with the expedition’s cat, Vic. She survived until a rescue party reached the island in 1923. Her young son had been left in Alaska while she was away. These facts provide context, but they do not tell us everything about Ada’s thoughts or choices.

These are newly written summaries of possible historical framings, not quotations from historical sources. A. Some newspaper accounts after the rescue presented Ada mainly as a dramatic survivor. This made her survival newsworthy, but could leave little room for her own perspective or the work she did on the expedition. B. Later writers interested in women’s history could ask why Ada’s endurance and practical knowledge had received less attention than the ambitions of male explorers. C. Historians today may examine the expedition’s colonial setting, the assumptions behind its territorial claim, and how Iñupiat identity shaped Ada’s experience. They can also ask whose evidence is preserved and whose voice is missing. A new interpretation does not automatically make an older account useless. Each account needs to be tested against evidence, context, purpose, and omissions.

Investigate the evidence

1.Which statement best distinguishes an event from an interpretation of its significance? Choose one.

Ada survived on Wrangel Island until a rescue party arrived; later accounts may differ in what they consider most important about that survival.
Ada’s survival proves that all newspaper accounts were fair and complete.
The expedition’s aim and Ada’s experiences are interpretations rather than historical events.
Historical significance is a fixed ranking that cannot change.

2.Match each evidence-card framing to the question it most directly raises. Write A, B, or C beside each question.

Who had the power to claim territory, and what assumptions supported that claim?
Why might the survival story have attracted attention while Ada’s own perspective was less visible?
Why might a writer compare attention given to Ada with attention given to male explorers?

3.Select two factors that can help explain why historians ask different questions about Ada’s story today than some earlier accounts did.

Changing interest in women’s history and Indigenous perspectives
The past itself changing after the event
New questions about colonialism and who gets to tell history
The certainty that every later account is more accurate

4.Complete the idea using evidence from the cards: Ada’s historical significance is not fixed because historians can .

5.Evidence card A says a survival-focused account could leave little room for Ada’s perspective. Give one detail from the context card that an account centred only on dramatic survival might overlook.

6.A historian argues: “Ada should be remembered only as a heroic survivor.” Identify one strength and one limitation of this interpretation, using the evidence cards.

7.True or false? A later interpretation of Ada’s story is automatically more reliable just because it was written more recently. Explain your choice in one sentence.

8.The context card states that the expedition aimed to claim Wrangel Island for Canada. Explain how this detail could change the way a historian interprets the expedition, compared with an account focused only on exploration and survival.

9.Imagine you are planning a short museum panel about Ada Blackjack for visitors in Aotearoa New Zealand. Write a heading and two sentences that recognise her survival while avoiding a one-dimensional account. Use at least two details from the evidence cards.

10.Explain the statement: “The stories societies choose to emphasise can reveal present-day values.” Use Ada’s changing historical significance as your example, and include one caution about this idea.