Social SciencesFreePrintable

Government Systems Comparison Chart

A free social sciences worksheet ready for your classroom. Open in Kuraplan to grab the print-ready PDF, customize it for your students, or generate a fresh version in seconds.

Download now

Name:Date:

Government Systems Comparison Chart

A local group is planning a kiwi recovery project. Finn, Hana and Nikau need to understand how decisions might be made under different government systems. Read the briefing, then compare systems and apply your knowledge. Remember: real countries can combine features, and not every monarchy or democracy works in exactly the same way.

Briefing: three ways power can be organised

In a democracy, citizens have a meaningful way to influence government, often by voting in regular elections. Elected representatives may debate and pass laws. Democratic systems can protect rights, but decisions may take time and citizens can disagree about priorities. In a monarchy, a monarch is the head of state. In a constitutional monarchy, such as New Zealand, the monarch’s role is limited by law and elected representatives make government decisions. In an absolute monarchy, the monarch has much greater governing power. Monarchies are not all alike. In a dictatorship, one leader or a small group holds most political power, with little meaningful public choice over who governs. Elections, if held, may not be free or fair. Opposition and media can be restricted. Some authoritarian governments use laws and institutions, but these do not necessarily provide genuine checks on those in power. For the kiwi project, imagine a proposal to protect a forest area, fund predator-control work and ask nearby communities for feedback. The system of government affects who can make these decisions, how people can challenge them, and how accountable leaders are.

Part A: Spot the differences

Use the briefing above for Questions 1–4.

1.Which statement best describes how citizens influence government in a democracy?

They can meaningfully influence government, often by voting in regular elections.
They inherit the right to govern from a parent.
They have no way to influence government decisions.

2.New Zealand is a constitutional monarchy. What does that mean for decisions such as funding predator-control work?

3.Finn says, “Any country with a monarch must be ruled by that monarch alone.” Is Finn’s claim accurate? Explain using a key term from the briefing.

4.Which two features most strongly suggest that a government is a dictatorship rather than a democracy?

Little meaningful public choice over leaders and restrictions on opposition or media
Regular meaningful elections and open debate
A monarch as head of state and elected representatives making decisions

Part B: Compare and apply

Consider who makes decisions, how people can influence them, and what checks might limit the use of power.

5.Match each feature to the system whose defining characteristic it describes in the briefing. These are defining characteristics, not claims that systems cannot share features. A system may be used more than once. Features: (a) citizens can choose representatives in meaningful elections; (b) a monarch’s governing role is limited by law; (c) one leader or a small group holds most political power and public choice is limited. Systems: democracy; constitutional monarchy; dictatorship.

(a) Meaningful elections for representatives
(b) Monarch’s role limited by law
(c) Power concentrated with limited public choice

Constitutional monarchy
Democracy
Dictatorship

6.In a country with a constitutional monarchy and an elected parliament, who would normally decide whether to fund the kiwi recovery project: the monarch or elected representatives? Give one reason.

7.Hana wants nearby communities to comment on the forest protection proposal. Which government system is most likely to offer citizens regular ways to influence public decisions? Explain one way they might do so.

8.Nikau argues that a dictatorship could approve the project faster than a democracy. Give one possible advantage of concentrated power and one important risk for people affected by the decision.

9.A government holds elections, but opposition candidates are blocked from campaigning and news outlets are controlled by the state. Does the presence of elections alone prove that the country is a democracy? Explain.

10.Write a brief recommendation to Finn, Hana and Nikau: name one feature of government that helps people have a say in the kiwi project, and one safeguard that can help prevent leaders from misusing power.