EnglishFreePrintable

Cultural Representation Analysis

A free english worksheet ready for your classroom. Open in Kuraplan to grab the print-ready PDF, customize it for your students, or generate a fresh version in seconds.

Download now

Name:Date:

Cultural Representation Analysis

Read the two fictional media extracts below. Then analyse how language, point of view and character roles shape cultural representation. Support written responses with details from the extracts. There may be more than one defensible interpretation.

Two ways of telling the same story

Both extracts are from fictional local media reports about a proposed night market in the Australian suburb of Riverton. The market is organised by residents from several cultural backgrounds. EXTRACT A — Riverton’s ‘Exotic’ Night Market A burst of colour is coming to Riverton this Saturday, when the suburb’s newest night market transforms the ordinary car park into a faraway spectacle. Visitors can sample mysterious spices, watch lively dances and meet the hardworking families bringing their colourful traditions to Australia. Council representatives hope the event will attract tourists and brighten a quiet corner of town. Organiser Matilda Rahman says the market is also a chance for local businesses to earn income, but the real draw is the chance to experience something different without leaving Riverton. EXTRACT B — Residents build a market around local food and music Riverton residents have spent six months planning a night market that will bring food, music and small businesses together in the suburb. Organiser Matilda Rahman says the idea began when stallholders at a community cooking group wanted a regular place to sell their products. “We chose the music and menu together,” she says. “It’s not a display of one culture. It’s a place where neighbours can meet, trade and make something of our own.” The council has provided the car park and a small grant; residents will decide how the market develops after its first season.

1.Which extract more strongly presents the market as an event created by local residents, and what detail supports your choice?

2.In Extract A, what associations might the words “exotic”, “mysterious” and “faraway” create for the audience? Explain how these words position the market.

3.Which statement best describes an important difference in point of view between the extracts?

Extract A focuses on the market as a spectacle for visitors, while Extract B gives residents more agency and explains their aims.
Extract A is written by a stallholder, while Extract B is written by a council representative.
Extract B describes the market as a tourist attraction, while Extract A rejects tourism.
Both extracts present the organisers’ views in exactly the same way.

4.In Extract B, Matilda says, “It’s not a display of one culture.” What assumption about the market does this statement challenge?

5.True or false: Extract A includes Matilda’s practical reason for supporting the market, but its final sentence shifts attention back to what visitors can experience.

TrueFalse

6.Match each writing choice with its most likely effect in these extracts.

A. Calling the market a “faraway spectacle”
B. Explaining that stallholders wanted a regular place to sell
C. Quoting Matilda directly

2. Gives residents a practical motive and a role in initiating the project
1. Presents the event as an attraction for an outside audience
3. Allows an organiser to express her perspective in her own words

7.Name one perspective or piece of information that is missing from both extracts and explain how including it could make the reporting more complete.

8.How might a reader’s impression of the market organisers differ after reading Extract A rather than Extract B? Use one specific detail from each extract.

9.Which extract gives the more balanced representation of the market, in your view? Support your judgement with two textual details. You may also identify a limitation in the extract you choose.

10.Rewrite the phrase “a faraway spectacle” from Extract A so that it describes the market without presenting it as an exotic display. Then explain why your replacement changes the framing.