EnglishFreePrintable

Fate vs Free Will Viewing

A free english worksheet ready for your classroom. Open in Kuraplan to grab the print-ready PDF, customize it for your students, or generate a fresh version in seconds.

Download now

Name:Date:

Fate vs Free Will Viewing

Read the original story below as if you were viewing a short film. Then answer the questions using details from the story. For analysis questions, more than one interpretation may be valid; sample answers are provided.

The Lighthouse Signal

At 6:17 pm, Mara’s phone buzzed with a message from her brother: DON'T TAKE THE COAST ROAD. The message had arrived three minutes earlier, though the signal at the lookout was usually hopeless. Mara stared at the two routes below her. The coast road curved past the lighthouse, where a storm warning flashed red against the clouds. The inland track led to town, where her little brother Eli was waiting at the library. Their mum had asked Mara to collect him by seven. She had promised she would. Then the lighthouse beam went dark. A minute later, a second message appeared: I SAW THE LIGHT GO OUT. PLEASE GO HOME. Mara felt the old tug of the family story. Her grandfather had once said that everyone in their family was “called to the sea” sooner or later. He had been a rescue volunteer for years. When Mara was little, she imagined the sea choosing people, the way a coach selected a team. She could follow the coast road and check whether anyone needed help. She could take the inland track and keep her promise. Or she could call emergency services, explain what she had seen, and let trained rescuers decide what to do. Her phone showed one bar of reception. Mara called. The operator asked for the lighthouse location and the time the beam had gone out. Mara gave both details, then stayed on the line while the operator contacted the coastguard. A voice crackled back: a maintenance worker was safe inside the lighthouse, but the storm had damaged the power system. The danger was not over. The coastguard asked Mara to remain at the lookout and direct a volunteer crew when they arrived. She could still leave for town. Eli would be worried, and she had promised to collect him. She sent him a message: I’m safe. I’ve called for help. I’ll explain soon. When the crew reached the lookout, Mara pointed out the safest track. She did not go to the lighthouse. She did not ignore the warning, either. Later, she met Eli at the library. He was cross, but relieved. “Maybe the sea called you,” he said. “Maybe,” Mara replied. “But I chose to answer the phone first.”

Reading the story

Look for the difference between events Mara cannot control and decisions she makes for herself.

1.At the beginning, Mara receives a message warning her not to take the coast road. What detail makes the message seem unusual?

2.Which choice does Mara make after the lighthouse beam goes dark?

She takes the coast road alone to investigate.
She calls emergency services and reports what she has seen.
She ignores the messages and goes straight to the library.
She waits until the storm passes before telling anyone.

3.Mara remembers her grandfather saying that their family is “called to the sea”. Is this proof that Mara’s actions are predetermined? Explain your interpretation using one story detail.

4.True or false: Mara abandons her promise to Eli without contacting him.

TrueFalse

5.Complete the sentence: The moment the lighthouse beam goes dark is a turning point because it .

6.Match each detail from the story with the effect it has on the reader.

The phone shows one bar of reception.
The lighthouse beam goes dark.
Eli says, “Maybe the sea called you.”

Signals a problem and triggers the central decision.
Creates uncertainty about whether Mara can get help.
Reopens the question of fate at the ending.

7.Name one event Mara cannot control and one decision she can control. Explain how the contrast develops the story’s theme.

8.What does Mara mean when she says, “I chose to answer the phone first”? How does the line support the title’s idea of fate versus free will?

9.The story stays close to Mara’s thoughts, including her memory of the family story. How does this point of view shape the reader’s understanding of her choice?

10.Write a different final line for the story that makes Mara sound more convinced that fate guided her. Then explain how your line changes the original ending’s message.