Excellent: Clear, descriptive title and objective that perfectly explains the purpose

Good: Clear title and objective with minor unclear details

Satisfactory: Title and objective present but could be clearer

Needs Improvement: Title or objective missing or very unclear

Excellent: All steps in perfect logical order, clearly numbered

Good: Steps mostly in logical order with clear numbering

Satisfactory: Most steps in order but some confusion

Needs Improvement: Steps out of order or numbering unclear

Excellent: Consistently uses appropriate imperative verbs throughout

Good: Uses imperative verbs in most steps

Satisfactory: Some use of imperative verbs

Needs Improvement: Rarely uses imperative verbs

Excellent: Uses sequencing words effectively throughout

Good: Uses sequencing words in most appropriate places

Satisfactory: Some use of sequencing words

Needs Improvement: Rarely uses sequencing words

Excellent: Very clear, precise language that's easy to follow

Good: Mostly clear language with minor unclear parts

Satisfactory: Generally clear but some confusing sections

Needs Improvement: Language often unclear or confusing

Excellent: Complete, clear list of all materials needed

Good: Most materials listed clearly

Satisfactory: Some materials listed but incomplete

Needs Improvement: Materials list missing or very incomplete

Excellent: Clear, helpful visuals that enhance understanding

Good: Visuals present and mostly helpful

Satisfactory: Some visuals but not very clear or helpful

Needs Improvement: No visuals or visuals are confusing

Excellent: Easy to follow, would work perfectly as instructions

Good: Generally easy to follow with minor issues

Satisfactory: Workable but needs some improvements

Needs Improvement: Difficult to follow, needs major improvements