Social SciencesFreePrintable

Robber Barons Group Worksheet

A free social sciences worksheet ready for your classroom. Open in Kuraplan to grab the print-ready PDF, customize it for your students, or generate a fresh version in seconds.

Download now

Name:Date:

Robber Barons Group Worksheet

Work with a partner or small group to investigate why some late-19th-century American industrialists were called “Robber Barons”. Read the source, study the comparison grid, and use evidence to weigh their achievements against the costs. Then complete the questions. The term is contested: it reflects a critical judgement, not a neutral job title.

Source: wealth and power in the Gilded Age

In the United States after the Civil War, railways, steel and oil industries expanded rapidly. New technologies and large-scale production helped make goods cheaper and transport faster. The period from about the 1870s to 1900 is often called the Gilded Age: “gilded” suggests a shiny surface that may hide serious problems. Some industrialists built enormous fortunes. Andrew Carnegie’s company became a leading steel producer. John D. Rockefeller’s Standard Oil grew powerful in the oil-refining industry. A railway entrepreneur made much of his fortune in transportation. These businesses could lower costs through efficiencies and, in some cases, by controlling several stages of production or distribution. This practice is called vertical integration. Supporters argued that ambitious business leaders created jobs, expanded industries and helped build infrastructure. Carnegie also gave large sums to libraries and education. Critics pointed to low wages, long hours, dangerous workplaces, harsh treatment of workers and pressure on competitors. Standard Oil used deals and price-cutting tactics to gain control of much of the oil-refining trade. When one business dominates an industry and limits competition, it may be described as a monopoly. The label “Robber Baron” expresses the view that some wealthy industrialists gained power by exploiting workers or unfairly weakening rivals. Others preferred “captains of industry”, emphasising investment, innovation and philanthropy. Neither label alone explains the whole story. Historians weigh evidence and ask who benefited, who paid the costs, and how much power a business should have.

Person

Industry

Possible benefit and criticism

Andrew Carnegie

Steel

Benefit: expanded steel production; gave money to libraries and education. Criticism: steelmaking could involve dangerous work and harsh conditions.

John D. Rockefeller

Oil refining

Benefit: made refining more efficient. Criticism: Standard Oil gained extensive control and used tactics that weakened competition.

Cornelius Vanderbilt

Railways

Benefit: helped expand transport networks. Criticism: concentrated railway power could give owners great influence over routes and rates.

Discuss and investigate

Share ideas before writing. Build on a partner’s point, ask what evidence supports it, and consider whose perspective may be missing.

1.In the source, what does “Gilded Age” suggest about the contrast between the period’s appearance and its problems?

2.Which person in the comparison grid built a fortune in railways?

Andrew Carnegie
John D. Rockefeller
Cornelius Vanderbilt
None of them

3.Explain vertical integration in your own words. Include how it could help a business.

4.True or false? The source says that philanthropy completely cancels out criticism of an industrialist’s business practices. Explain your choice.

5.Match each term to its meaning.

Monopoly
Philanthropy
Exploitation

Giving money or resources to benefit others
One business dominates an industry and limits competition
Taking unfair advantage of people, such as workers

6.Complete the sentence with one key term: When a company dominates its industry and restricts competition, it may become a .

7.Give one benefit and one cost of the industrialists’ growing businesses, using evidence from the source or grid.

8.A group member says, “Carnegie gave money to libraries, so he could not have been a Robber Baron.” Write a response that weighs this claim rather than simply agreeing or disagreeing.

9.Which label is better supported by the source for John D. Rockefeller: “captain of industry” or “Robber Baron”? Choose one and give two pieces of evidence. You may argue that both labels capture part of the story.

10.In your group, agree on one discussion question about concentrated business power that could also matter in Australia today. Write the question and explain one useful connection to the history in this worksheet.