Creating Strong Opinions

Curriculum Area: English Language Arts

Grade Level: 10th Grade

---

Duration: 45 minutes
Class Size: 32 students
Standards: Aligns with the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) in English Language Arts for Grade 10, specifically focusing on CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.9-10.1 (Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence).

---

Learning Objectives

• Students will understand the difference between an opinion and an assertion.
• Students will learn how to formulate a clear and concise statement of opinion or assertion.
• Students will practice applying their statements of opinion in both written and spoken formats.

---

Materials Needed

• Whiteboard and markers
• Projector and screen for displaying video clips
• Printed handouts of a short opinion article
• Paper and writing utensils
• Index cards with prompts
• Sticky notes

---

Lesson Outline

1. Anticipation (10 minutes)

• Activity 1: Opinion Poll

  • Objective: Engage students in thinking about opinions they hold.
  • Instructions:
    • Pose a thought-provoking question to the class (e.g., "Is social media beneficial for society?").
    • Have students write their opinion on an index card.
    • Conduct a quick show of hands to gauge the overall class opinion.

• Activity 2: Video Clip Viewing

  • Objective: Model an example of opinion and assertion.
  • Instructions:
    • Play a 2-minute video clip featuring a well-articulated opinion from a social commentary.
    • Ask students to identify the speaker's main opinion.

2. Analysis (10 minutes)

• Discussion and Instruction: Distinguish Opinion from Assertion
  • Objective: Differentiate between opinion and assertion, ensuring students understand key characteristics.
  • Instructions:
    • Write definitions on the board:
      • Opinion: A personal belief or judgment not founded on proof or certainty.
      • Assertion: A confident and forceful statement of fact or belief.
    • Discuss as a class, using a relevant example from the video.

3. Application (15 minutes)

• Activity 1: Reading and Identifying (Reading & Listening)

  • Objective: Develop comprehension and analytical skills through reading.
  • Instructions:
    • Distribute copies of a short opinion article.
    • In pairs, have students read and listen as they take turns reading aloud.
    • On sticky notes, students jot down the author's main opinion and any assertions.

• Activity 2: Writing a Statement (Writing)

  • Objective: Practice formulating a statement of opinion.
  • Instructions:
    • Each student selects a topic related to the article (e.g., "The impact of technology on education").
    • Write one clear and concise statement of opinion regarding their chosen topic.

4. Assessment (10 minutes)

• Activity: Opinion Roundtable (Speaking & Listening)

  • Objective: Develop speaking and listening skills through sharing and feedback.
  • Instructions:
    • Form small groups of 4-5 students.
    • Each student reads their statement aloud.
    • Group members provide constructive feedback: Is the opinion clear? Is there an assertion present?

• Closure and Reflection

  • Objective: Reflect on the learning experience.
  • Instructions:
    • Ask students to share one thing they learned about forming an opinion or assertion.
    • Collect sticky notes from the reading activity for informal assessment.

---

Differentiation Strategies

• For Advanced Students: Encourage them to incorporate evidence or reasoning supporting their opinion statements.
• For Students Needing Support: Provide sentence starters or opinion templates to help guide their writing.
• For Diverse Learners: Offer visual aids and model examples for clarity. Pair students strategically for peer support.

---

Reflection and Follow-Up

• Teachers can reflect on the effectiveness of the lesson by reviewing students' written statements and listening to group feedback during the roundtable.
• Encourage students to think of other areas where they can apply their skills in forming opinion statements, such as in debates or essays.
• Consider a follow-up activity where students research evidence to support one of the opinions they heard in class.