Grade 8 · English Language Arts · 2 minutes
Prove it: citing text evidence
Claim. Evidence. Explanation.
Key terms
- Claim
- An idea or answer to a question that you then have to prove with evidence.
- Evidence
- Words from the text that point straight at your claim and prove it.
- Signal phrase
- Words like according to the text that lead into a quote instead of just dropping it in.
- Cite
- To show where a piece of evidence comes from in the text.
- RACE
- A reminder to restate the question, answer with a claim, cite strong evidence and explain how it proves your point.
Transcript
Anyone can say something about a story. But can you prove it? Strong readers back up every claim with evidence from the text.
Let's try it. Maya waited backstage, gripping her violin so tightly that her knuckles turned white. She checked the exit twice. When her name was called, she took a slow breath and walked into the light.
Here's the question: how does Maya feel before she performs? First, restate it and answer. Before she performs, Maya feels nervous. That's my claim, an idea I now have to prove.
So where's the proof? Look closely. Gripping her violin so tightly that her knuckles turned white. That's my evidence.
But not all evidence is equal. Maya waited backstage is true, but it doesn't show she's nervous. Strong evidence points straight at your claim.
Next, don't just drop the quote in. Lead in with a signal phrase, like according to the text, or the author writes. The author writes that Maya is gripping her violin so tightly that her knuckles turned white.
Finally, explain how that evidence proves your claim. White knuckles show how tense she is. Her body reveals the fear she won't say out loud. Your explanation is the bridge between the quote and the claim.
So remember RACE. Restate the question, answer it with a claim, cite strong evidence, and explain how it proves your point. Now go prove it!
Sources
Every fact in the video, and where it comes from.
- 1thecorestandards.org/ELA-Literacy/RL/8
- CCSS RL.8.1 / RI.8.1: cite the textual evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text.
- 2twinkl.com/teaching-wiki/race-writing-strategy
- RACE = Restate the question, Answer it, Cite evidence from the text, Explain how the evidence supports the answer.
- 3owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/using_research/quoti…
- Signal (lead-in) phrases such as 'according to' and 'the author writes' introduce quotations and paraphrases; most use a reporting verb.
Teaching this next week?
Kuraplan turns this topic into a lesson plan, slides and a worksheet for your class in about a minute.
Plan a lesson on this topic