English (ELA)FreePrintable

Text Synthesis and Comparison

A free english (ela) worksheet ready for your classroom. Open in Kuraplan to grab the print-ready PDF, customize it for your students, or generate a fresh version in seconds.

Download now

Name:Date:

Text Synthesis and Comparison

Read both short texts about urban gardens. Then compare the information and use ideas from both texts to build a fuller understanding.

Text 1: A Garden on the Roof

At the top of a six-story apartment building in Chicago, a once-empty roof has become a community garden. Neighbors grow tomatoes, lettuce, beans, and herbs in large containers filled with soil. The garden is open from spring through fall, and volunteers take turns watering and weeding. The garden helps people in several ways. Residents can pick fresh vegetables close to home, and the plants provide shade that can make the roof cooler on hot days. The garden also gives neighbors a place to meet. Some volunteers say they have made friends while working beside people they had only passed in the elevator before. Growing food on a roof takes planning. The containers must be sturdy enough to hold wet soil, and gardeners need a reliable way to carry water upstairs. They also check that the roof can safely support the garden’s weight. The project began with a small group of residents, but more people joined after they saw the first harvest.

Text 2: Why City Gardens Matter

City gardens can do more than grow food. In neighborhoods with few parks, a garden can create a green place where people can gather. Plants can offer insects and birds places to find food or shelter. Their leaves can also catch some rainwater before it runs across streets and sidewalks. A garden does not need a rooftop to make a difference. People grow plants in schoolyards, empty lots, balconies, and shared outdoor spaces. Some gardens focus on vegetables, while others grow flowers that attract pollinators such as bees and butterflies. Many are cared for by volunteers who share tools, seeds, and gardening advice. Every garden has limits. A small space cannot provide all the food a neighborhood needs, and plants require water, sunlight, and care. Still, community gardens can help people connect with one another and notice more of the living things around them. When neighbors plan together, they can choose plants and garden spaces that fit local needs.

Read, Compare, and Synthesize

Use evidence from the two texts. A strong answer may paraphrase the texts or include a short quotation.

1.Which statement best expresses the main idea of “A Garden on the Roof”?

A rooftop garden can provide fresh food and bring neighbors together, but it requires careful planning.
All apartment buildings should replace their roofs with gardens.
Growing vegetables is easy when people have large containers.
Neighbors usually know one another before they start gardening.

2.Write two details from Text 1 that show how the rooftop garden benefits residents.

3.What is the main focus of “Why City Gardens Matter”?

The steps for building a rooftop garden
Ways city gardens can help people and nature, along with their limits
A list of vegetables that grow best in Chicago
Why every garden should be cared for by volunteers

4.Which two ideas appear in both texts? Select both correct answers.

Gardens can help people connect with one another.
Gardens can be cared for by people working together.
Every city garden must grow tomatoes.
Gardens provide all the food a neighborhood needs.

5.Give one detail that appears only in Text 1 and one detail that appears only in Text 2.

6.How does Text 2 add to what you learn from Text 1? Include one new idea from Text 2.

7.A neighbor says, “Our garden is small, so it cannot help our community.” Which idea from the texts best challenges this claim? Explain your choice.

8.Write a paragraph explaining what the two texts together teach about city gardens. Include one similarity, one difference, and evidence from both texts.

9.Combine one detail from each text to make a conclusion about how city gardens can affect the local environment. Include the detail from Text 1 about shade and the detail from Text 2 about rainwater.